Failure to complete a functional restoration program for chronic musculoskeletal disorders: a prospective 1-year outcome study.

OBJECTIVE

To compare comprehensively the likelihood of various socioeconomically relevant outcomes between functional restoration completers and noncompleters, while simultaneously identifying risk factors for noncompletion.

DESIGN

A prospective cohort study of patients with chronic disabling occupational musculoskeletal disorders (CDOMD).

SETTING

Chronic pain management facility.

PARTICIPANTS

A total of 1440 patients with CDOMD were consecutively divided into 2 groups-one with 303 patients who did not complete the prescribed treatment program (noncompleters [NC]) and a second with 1137 patients who did (completers).

INTERVENTION

The Interdisciplinary Functional Restoration: Rehabilitation program.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Validated questionnaires about pain, disability, and depression were added to results of a structured 1-year posttreatment telephone interview on socioeconomic outcomes covering work status, health utilization, recurrent injury claims, and resolution of financial disputes.

RESULTS

The 1-year posttreatment socioeconomic outcomes were most striking. The NC group was 7 times more likely to have postrehabilitation surgery in the same area, and nearly 7 times more likely to have more than 30 visits to a new health provider in persistent health care-seeking efforts. The NC group also had only half the rates of work return and work retention, being 9.7 times less likely to have returned to any type of work, and 7 times less likely to have retained work at the end of the year. Regression analysis also revealed that work return, surgery in a compensable injured area, more health care utilization from a new provider, and more overall health care utilization (>30 visits) were most reliably predicted by whether the rehabilitation program was completed.

CONCLUSIONS

This large prospective study determined that noncompleters of interdisciplinary tertiary rehabilitation for CDOMDs had comparatively poor socioeconomic outcomes in the year after discharge from treatment, especially on work status and health utilization outcomes. These outcomes are of great relevance to societal, medical, and indemnity costs and future worker productivity. Several risk factors of possible importance in identifying potential noncompleters early in the treatment program were identified that may yield more effective interventions tailored to maintain compliance and decrease the percentage of drop-outs.