Bauder T A, Barbarick K A, Ippolito J A, Shanahan J F, Ayers P D
Department of Soil and Crop Science, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO 80523, USA.
J Environ Qual. 2005 Aug 9;34(5):1687-96. doi: 10.2134/jeq2004.0384. Print 2005 Sep-Oct.
Oil and gas drilling operations use drilling fluids (mud) to lubricate the drill bit and stem, transport formation cuttings to the surface, and seal off porous geologic formations. Following completion of the well, waste drilling fluid is often applied to cropland. We studied potential changes in soil compaction as indicated by cone penetration resistance, pH, electrical conductivity (EC(e)), sodium adsorption ratio (SAR), extractable soil and total straw and grain trace metal and nutrient concentrations, and winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L. 'TAM 107') grain yield following water-based, bentonitic drilling-fluid application (0-94 Mg ha(-1)) to field test plots. Three methods of application (normal, splash-plate, and spreader-bar) were used to study compaction effects. We measured increasing SAR, EC(e), and pH with drilling-fluid rates, but not to levels detrimental to crop production. Field measurements revealed significantly higher compaction within areas affected by truck travel, but also not enough to affect crop yield. In three of four site years, neither drilling-fluid rate nor application method affected grain yield. Extractions representing plant availability and plant analyses results indicated that drilling fluid did not significantly increase most trace elements or nutrient concentrations. These results support land application of water-based bentonitic drilling fluids as an acceptable practice on well-drained soils using controlled rates.
石油和天然气钻井作业使用钻井液(泥浆)来润滑钻头和钻杆,将地层岩屑输送到地面,并封闭多孔地质层。完井后,废弃钻井液常被施用于农田。我们研究了在田间试验地块施用不同用量(0至94 Mg ha(-1))的水基膨润土钻井液后,土壤压实度的潜在变化,这些变化通过圆锥贯入阻力、pH值、电导率(EC(e))、钠吸附比(SAR)、可提取土壤以及秸秆和谷物中的总微量金属和养分浓度来体现,同时还研究了对冬小麦(Triticum aestivum L. 'TAM 107')产量的影响。采用了三种施用方法(常规法、溅盘法和撒布棒法)来研究压实效果。我们发现,随着钻井液用量增加,SAR、EC(e)和pH值也升高,但未达到对作物生产有害的水平。实地测量表明,受卡车行驶影响的区域压实度显著更高,但也不足以影响作物产量。在四个试验年份中的三个年份,钻井液用量和施用方法均未影响谷物产量。代表植物有效性的提取结果和植物分析结果表明,钻井液并未显著提高大多数微量元素或养分的浓度。这些结果支持在排水良好的土壤上以可控用量将水基膨润土钻井液用于土地的做法是可接受的。