Spinewine Anne, Swine Christian, Dhillon Soraya, Franklin Bryony Dean, Tulkens Paul M, Wilmotte Léon, Lorant Vincent
Centre for Clinical Pharmacy, School of Pharmacy, Université catholique de Louvain, 1200 Brussels, Belgium.
BMJ. 2005 Oct 22;331(7522):935. doi: 10.1136/bmj.38551.410012.06. Epub 2005 Aug 10.
To explore the processes leading to inappropriate use of medicines for elderly patients admitted for acute care.
Qualitative study with semistructured interviews with doctors, nurses, and pharmacists; focus groups with inpatients; and observation on the ward by clinical pharmacists for one month.
Five acute wards for care of the elderly in Belgium.
5 doctors, 4 nurses, and 3 pharmacists from five acute wards for the interviews; all professionals and patients on two acute wards for the observation and 17 patients (from the same two wards) for the focus groups.
Several factors contributed to inappropriate prescribing, counselling, and transfer of information on medicines to primary care. Firstly, review of treatment was driven by acute considerations, the transfer of information on medicines from primary to secondary care was limited, and prescribing was often not tailored to elderly patients. Secondly, some doctors had a passive attitude towards learning: they thought it would take too long to find the information they needed about medicines and lacked self directed learning. Finally, a paternalistic doctor-patient relationship and difficulties in sharing decisions about treatment between prescribers led to inappropriate use of medicines. Several factors, such as the input of geriatricians and good communication between members of the multidisciplinary geriatric team, led to better use of medicines.
In this setting, improvements targeted at the abilities of individuals, better doctor-patient and doctor-doctor relationships, and systems for transferring information between care settings will increase the appropriate use of medicines in elderly people.
探讨导致入住急性护理病房的老年患者用药不当的过程。
采用定性研究方法,对医生、护士和药剂师进行半结构式访谈;对住院患者进行焦点小组讨论;临床药剂师在病房进行为期一个月的观察。
比利时的五个老年急性护理病房。
来自五个急性护理病房的5名医生、4名护士和3名药剂师参与访谈;两个急性护理病房的所有专业人员和患者参与观察,17名患者(来自相同的两个病房)参与焦点小组讨论。
有几个因素导致了用药处方不当、用药咨询不当以及向初级护理机构传递用药信息不当。首先,治疗评估受急性病症因素驱动,从初级护理机构到二级护理机构的用药信息传递有限,而且处方往往没有针对老年患者量身定制。其次,一些医生对学习持消极态度:他们认为查找所需药物信息耗时过长,且缺乏自主学习能力。最后,家长式的医患关系以及开处方者之间在治疗决策共享方面存在困难,导致用药不当。而一些因素,如老年病专家的参与以及多学科老年护理团队成员之间的良好沟通,则有助于更合理地用药。
在这种情况下,针对个人能力的提升、改善医患及医生之间的关系以及建立不同护理机构间信息传递系统,将有助于提高老年人用药的合理性。