Simons Wim, Dierick Michel
University Centre St. Jozef, Catholic University of Leuven, Kortenberg, Belgium.
World J Biol Psychiatry. 2005;6(1):6-25. doi: 10.1080/15622970510029812.
Transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) is a patient-friendly stimulation technique of the brain with interesting perspectives. In clinical psychiatry, limited data are available on activity in psychosis and anxiety, but much research has been done in depression. Major concerns on published papers are the inconsistency of used parameter settings, the restraint numbers of patients in randomised trials, the lack of real sham controlled studies and the quasi inexistent reproducibility of results. The most stringent meta-analysis of TMS in affective disorders found a modest, statistically significant antidepressant effect after 2 weeks of daily treatment of high frequency repetitive left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex stimulation. Although most results are rather weak and not convincing enough to promote TMS as evidence-based antidepressive therapy, they show a measurable action that should not be ignored. Preclinical and clinical effects were observed analysing heterogeneous data, and results comparing TMS to electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) in affective disorders are encouraging. Efforts should continue with emphasis on increasing homogeneity and reproducibility in data. Further refinement of stimulation parameters should be established, so that new and large double-blind, long-term, sham-controlled trials can bring us to better understanding and standardising TMS procedure, finally leading to definitive conclusions about its efficacy in psychiatry.
经颅磁刺激(TMS)是一种对患者友好的脑部刺激技术,具有有趣的前景。在临床精神病学中,关于精神病和焦虑症活动的数据有限,但在抑郁症方面已经进行了大量研究。已发表论文的主要问题包括所使用参数设置的不一致性、随机试验中患者数量的限制、缺乏真正的假对照研究以及结果几乎不存在可重复性。对TMS在情感障碍中最严格的荟萃分析发现,在每天高频重复刺激左侧背外侧前额叶皮层2周后,有适度的、具有统计学意义的抗抑郁作用。尽管大多数结果相当微弱,不足以令人信服地将TMS推广为基于证据的抗抑郁治疗方法,但它们显示出一种不可忽视的可测量作用。通过分析异质性数据观察到了临床前和临床效果,并且在情感障碍中将TMS与电休克疗法(ECT)进行比较的结果令人鼓舞。应继续努力,重点是提高数据的同质性和可重复性。应进一步完善刺激参数,以便新的、大规模的双盲、长期、假对照试验能使我们更好地理解并规范TMS程序,最终就其在精神病学中的疗效得出明确结论。