Ghosh A, Busby M, Kennett R, Mills K, Donaghy M
University Department of Clinical Neurology, Radcliffe Infirmary, Oxford OX2 6HE, UK.
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2005 Sep;76(9):1264-8. doi: 10.1136/jnnp.2004.047688.
Multifocal motor neuropathy with conduction block (MMN) can be mistaken for motor neurone disease or other lower motor neurone syndromes, but is treatable with intravenous immunoglobulin (IvIg). Formal electrophysiological criteria for conduction block (CB) are so stringent that substantial numbers of patients may miss out on appropriate treatment.
Electrophysiological data were collected from 10 healthy volunteers and compared to data from 10 patients who satisfied the clinical criteria for MMN and who responded to IvIg. This produced a definition of CB in MMN patients which was compared with existing definitions to assess "miss rates".
Mean values for compound muscle action potential area, amplitude, and duration were calculated in normal subjects. Results beyond 3 SD of their respective means were considered abnormal. Using these criteria, CB in the context of MMN was defined as a reduction in negative peak area >23% along a distal nerve segment or >29% across a proximal segment; or a reduction in amplitude >32% across a distal segment or >33% across a proximal segment. All IvIg responsive patients had at least one nerve segment showing such CB. Employing some criteria from the literature would have denied treatment to over 30% of responsive patients.
In the clinical setting of suspected MMN, less stringent criteria for CB can improve the diagnosis of this treatable disorder. Exclusions on grounds of temporal dispersion may be over-restrictive. A little over one third of CBs occur proximally.
伴有传导阻滞的多灶性运动神经病(MMN)可能被误诊为运动神经元病或其他下运动神经元综合征,但可通过静脉注射免疫球蛋白(IvIg)进行治疗。正式的传导阻滞(CB)电生理标准非常严格,以至于大量患者可能无法得到适当治疗。
收集10名健康志愿者的电生理数据,并与10名符合MMN临床标准且对IvIg有反应的患者的数据进行比较。由此得出MMN患者中CB的定义,并与现有定义进行比较以评估“漏诊率”。
计算正常受试者复合肌肉动作电位面积、波幅和时限的平均值。超出各自平均值3个标准差的结果被视为异常。使用这些标准,MMN背景下的CB定义为沿远端神经节段负峰面积减少>23%或跨近端节段减少>29%;或跨远端节段波幅减少>32%或跨近端节段减少>33%。所有对IvIg有反应的患者至少有一个神经节段显示出这种CB。采用文献中的一些标准会使超过30%有反应的患者得不到治疗。
在疑似MMN的临床情况下,对CB采用不太严格的标准可改善对这种可治疗疾病的诊断。基于时间离散度的排除可能过于严格。略多于三分之一的CB发生在近端。