Staudte H, Sigusch B W, Glockmann E
Department of Conservative Dentistry, Friedrich Schiller University, An der alten Post 4, 07750 Jena, Germany.
Br Dent J. 2005 Aug 27;199(4):213-7, discussion 210. doi: 10.1038/sj.bdj.4812613.
Previous studies demonstrate a relationship between a lack of vitamin C and increased risk of periodontal disease. In the present study we examine the vitamin C plasma levels and inflammatory measures in periodontitis patients before and after the consumption of grapefruit.
Fifty-eight patients with chronic periodontitis were assigned to the test group (non-smokers n=21, smokers n=17) and a diseased control group (non-smokers n=11, smokers n=9). Furthermore, 22 healthy subjects were recruited to compare vitamin C plasma levels between periodontally diseased and healthy subjects. Clinical evaluations, including plaque index (PI), sulcus bleeding index (SBI), probing pocket depths (PPD) and plasma vitamin C levels, were performed at baseline, and after two weeks of grapefruit consumption.
At baseline, we observed significantly reduced plasma vitamin C levels in the test group and diseased controls in comparison with the healthy controls. On principle, smokers showed lower levels of vitamin C (mean 0.39 +/- 0.17 mg dl(-1)) than non-smokers (mean 0.56+/-0.29 mg dl(-1)). After grapefruit consumption, the mean plasma vitamin C levels rose significantly in the test group compared to the diseased controls (non-smokers: 0.87+/-0.39 mg dl(-1), smokers: 0.74+/-0.30 mg dl(-1)). Furthermore the SBI was reduced in the test group (non-smokers: from 1.68+/-0.6 to 1.05+/-0.6, p<0.001), whereas PI and PPD were unaffected.
The present results show that periodontitis patients are characterised by plasma vitamin C levels below the normal range, especially in smokers. The intake of grapefruit leads to an increase in plasma vitamin C levels and improves sulcus bleeding scores. Longer term studies are necessary to determine whether other periodontal outcomes improve with such supplementation especially in smokers.
先前的研究表明维生素C缺乏与牙周病风险增加之间存在关联。在本研究中,我们检测了牙周炎患者食用葡萄柚前后的血浆维生素C水平及炎症指标。
58例慢性牙周炎患者被分为试验组(非吸烟者n = 21,吸烟者n = 17)和患病对照组(非吸烟者n = 11,吸烟者n = 9)。此外,招募了22名健康受试者以比较牙周病患者与健康受试者的血浆维生素C水平。在基线时以及食用葡萄柚两周后,进行了包括菌斑指数(PI)、龈沟出血指数(SBI)、探诊深度(PPD)和血浆维生素C水平在内的临床评估。
在基线时,我们观察到试验组和患病对照组的血浆维生素C水平相较于健康对照组显著降低。原则上,吸烟者的维生素C水平(平均0.39±0.17mg dl⁻¹)低于非吸烟者(平均0.56±0.29mg dl⁻¹)。食用葡萄柚后,试验组的平均血浆维生素C水平相较于患病对照组显著升高(非吸烟者:0.87±0.39mg dl⁻¹,吸烟者:0.74±0.30mg dl⁻¹)。此外,试验组的SBI降低(非吸烟者:从1.68±0.6降至1.05±0.6,p<0.001),而PI和PPD未受影响。
目前的结果表明,牙周炎患者的特征是血浆维生素C水平低于正常范围,尤其是吸烟者。摄入葡萄柚会导致血浆维生素C水平升高,并改善龈沟出血评分。需要进行更长期的研究以确定这种补充剂是否会改善其他牙周指标,特别是在吸烟者中。