Zaghloul M S, Awwad H K, Akoush H H, Omar S, Soliman O, el Attar I
Dept. of Radiotherapy, National Cancer Institute, Cairo, Egypt.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 1992;23(3):511-7. doi: 10.1016/0360-3016(92)90005-3.
Two hundred thirty-six patients with T3 bladder cancer who survived radical surgery and proved to have P3a, P3b, or P4a tumors were randomized in two phases into three groups: (a) no further treatment (83 patients); (b) postoperative radiotherapy multiple daily fractionation (MDF), using 3 daily fractions of 1.25 Gy each, with 3 hr between fractions, up to a total dose of 37.5 Gy in 12 days (75 patients); and (c) postoperative radiotherapy conventional fractionation (CF), for a total dose of 50 Gy/5 weeks (78 patients). The tolerance of the patients to postoperative radiotherapy was quite acceptable, with equal acute reactions in MDF and CF groups. The 5-year disease-free survival (DFS) rates amounted to 49 and 44% in MDF and CF postoperative radiotherapy groups, respectively, compared to 25% in the cystectomy-alone group. The 5-year local control rates were 87% and 93% for those treated with multiple daily fractionation and conventional fractionation while it was 50% in the surgery-alone group. The therapeutic benefit of postoperative irradiation was consistent for all tumor types, histological grades, and pathological stages for both the disease-free survival and local control. Patients with nodal metastases demonstrated lower recurrence rates in the postoperative radiotherapy groups, but this was not associated with improved disease-free survival. Multivariate analysis using the Cox Model confirmed these results. The independent prognostic factors affecting both disease-free survival and local control were the addition of postoperative radiotherapy, the nodal status, the pathological stage, and the tumor grade. Late complications of radiotherapy in the skin, small intestine, rectum, and the anastomotic site of the urinary division were lower with MDF than with conventional fractionation.
236例T3期膀胱癌患者在接受根治性手术后存活,且经证实患有P3a、P3b或P4a肿瘤,分两个阶段随机分为三组:(a) 不进行进一步治疗(83例患者);(b) 术后采用每日多次分割放疗(MDF),每天分3次给予1.25 Gy,每次分割间隔3小时,12天内总剂量达37.5 Gy(75例患者);(c) 术后采用常规分割放疗(CF),总剂量为50 Gy/5周(78例患者)。患者对术后放疗的耐受性相当良好,MDF组和CF组的急性反应相同。MDF组和CF组术后放疗的5年无病生存率分别为49%和44%,而单纯膀胱切除组为25%。每日多次分割放疗和常规分割放疗患者的5年局部控制率分别为87%和93%,而单纯手术组为50%。术后放疗对所有肿瘤类型、组织学分级和病理分期的无病生存和局部控制均有一致的治疗益处。有淋巴结转移的患者在术后放疗组的复发率较低,但这与无病生存率的改善无关。使用Cox模型进行的多因素分析证实了这些结果。影响无病生存和局部控制的独立预后因素包括术后放疗、淋巴结状态、病理分期和肿瘤分级。MDF组放疗后皮肤、小肠、直肠及泌尿生殖系统吻合口部位的晚期并发症低于常规分割放疗组。