Riegle E V, Gunter J B, Lusk R P, Muntz H R, Weiss K L
Department of Pediatric Anesthesiology, Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, MO.
Laryngoscope. 1992 Jul;102(7):820-3. doi: 10.1288/00005537-199207000-00012.
Three different vasoconstricting agents were evaluated during functional endoscopic sinus surgery (FESS) in 57 children. Oxymetazoline hydrochloride 0.05%, phenylephrine hydrochloride 0.25%, or cocaine 4% was applied to the nasal mucosa in a prospective, randomized, double-blind fashion. Heart rate and blood pressure changes were recorded 5 and 10 minutes after application of the study vasoconstrictor to each nostril. The surgeon's subjective impressions of bleeding and visualization were recorded for each side of the nose, as were total blood loss and anesthesia time. Although all three vasoconstrictors were tolerated well by the children, there was a suggestion that heart rate decreased more at 5 minutes with phenylephrine than with oxymetazoline or cocaine (P = .08) and that blood pressure increased more at 10 minutes with phenylephrine than with oxymetazoline or cocaine (P = .1). No arrhythmias were noted. Subjective scoring for bleeding showed that children receiving oxymetazoline were less likely to receive scores of "more" bleeding than usual (3/38 vs. 10/34 for phenylephrine and 10/35 for cocaine, P less than .02). Subjective scoring for visualization showed that children receiving oxymetazoline were also less likely to receive scores of "worse" visualization than usual (3/38 vs. 12/38 for phenylephrine and 9/35 for cocaine, P less than .01). There was no difference in surgical bleeding or visualization between children receiving phenylephrine and children receiving cocaine. In our institution, 0.05% oxymetazoline is the preferred vasoconstrictor for FESS in children.
在57名儿童的功能性鼻内镜鼻窦手术(FESS)中,对三种不同的血管收缩剂进行了评估。以前瞻性、随机、双盲的方式将0.05%的盐酸羟甲唑啉、0.25%的盐酸去氧肾上腺素或4%的可卡因应用于鼻黏膜。在向每个鼻孔应用研究用血管收缩剂后5分钟和10分钟记录心率和血压变化。记录外科医生对每侧鼻腔出血和视野的主观印象,以及总失血量和麻醉时间。尽管所有三种血管收缩剂在儿童中耐受性良好,但有迹象表明,与使用盐酸羟甲唑啉或可卡因相比,使用盐酸去氧肾上腺素后5分钟时心率下降更多(P = 0.08),且使用盐酸去氧肾上腺素后10分钟时血压升高比使用盐酸羟甲唑啉或可卡因时更多(P = 0.1)。未观察到心律失常。出血主观评分显示,接受盐酸羟甲唑啉的儿童比平时出现“更多”出血评分的可能性更小(盐酸羟甲唑啉组3/38,盐酸去氧肾上腺素组10/34,可卡因为10/35,P<0.02)。视野主观评分显示,接受盐酸羟甲唑啉的儿童比平时出现“更差”视野评分的可能性也更小(盐酸羟甲唑啉组3/38,盐酸去氧肾上腺素组12/38,可卡因为9/35,P<0.01)。接受盐酸去氧肾上腺素的儿童与接受可卡因的儿童在手术出血或视野方面没有差异。在我们机构,0.05%的盐酸羟甲唑啉是儿童FESS首选的血管收缩剂。