Ozer E M, Adams S H, Lustig J L, Millstein S G, Camfield K, El-Diwany S, Volpe S, Irwin C E
Department of Pediatrics, Division of Adolescent Medicine, School of Medicine, University of California, San Francisco, CA 94143-0503, USA.
Health Serv Res. 2001 Dec;36(6 Pt 2):150-65.
To evaluate the implementation of an intervention to increase the delivery of adolescent preventive services within a large managed care organization. Target health areas were tobacco, alcohol, sexual behavior, and safety (seat belt and helmet use).
DATA SOURCE/STUDY DESIGN: Adolescent reports of clinician screening and counseling were obtained from adolescents who attended well visits with their primary care providers. A prepost study design was used to evaluate the preventive services intervention. The intervention had three components: (1) 89 clinicians from three outpatient pediatric clinics attended a training to increase the delivery of preventive services; (2) customized adolescent screening and provider charting forms were integrated into the clinics; and (3) the resources of a health educator were provided to the clinics.
Following a visit, adolescents completed surveys reporting on clinician screening and counseling for each of the target risk areas. Preimplementation (three months), 104 adolescents completed surveys. Postimplementation of the training, tools, and health educator intervention, 211 adolescents completed surveys (five months). For 18 months postimplementation clinicians delivered services and 998 adolescents completed surveys.
Chi-square analyses of changes in screening from preimplementation to postimplementation showed that screening increased in all areas (p < .000), with an average increase in screening rates from 47 percent to 94 percent. Postimplementation counseling in all areas also increased significantly, with an average increase in counseling rates from 39 percent to 91 percent. There were slight decreases in screening from postimplementation to follow-up.
This study offers support for the efficacy of providing training, tools, and resources as a method for increasing preventive screening and counseling of adolescents across multiple risky health behaviors during a routine office visit.
评估在一家大型管理式医疗组织内为增加青少年预防服务的提供而实施的一项干预措施。目标健康领域包括烟草、酒精、性行为以及安全(安全带和头盔使用)。
数据来源/研究设计:青少年关于临床医生筛查和咨询的报告来自于那些与初级保健提供者进行健康检查的青少年。采用前后对照研究设计来评估预防服务干预措施。该干预措施有三个组成部分:(1)来自三家儿科门诊诊所的89名临床医生参加了旨在增加预防服务提供的培训;(2)定制的青少年筛查和医生记录表格被整合到诊所中;(3)向诊所提供了一名健康教育工作者的资源。
就诊后,青少年完成了关于临床医生对每个目标风险领域进行筛查和咨询的调查。实施前(三个月),104名青少年完成了调查。在培训、工具和健康教育工作者干预措施实施后(五个月),211名青少年完成了调查。在实施后的18个月里,临床医生提供服务,998名青少年完成了调查。
对实施前到实施后筛查变化的卡方分析表明,所有领域的筛查都有所增加(p < .000),筛查率平均从47%提高到94%。所有领域实施后的咨询也显著增加,咨询率平均从39%提高到91%。从实施后到随访期间,筛查略有下降。
本研究支持提供培训、工具和资源作为一种在常规门诊就诊期间增加对青少年多种危险健康行为的预防性筛查和咨询的方法的有效性。