Cohen Stanley, Shoup Angela, Weisman Michael H, Harris Jeffrey
Division of Rheumatology, St. Paul University Medical Center, Dallas, Texas 75235, USA.
Otol Neurotol. 2005 Sep;26(5):903-7. doi: 10.1097/01.mao.0000185082.28598.87.
Autoimmune Inner Ear Disease (AIED) is an idiopathic progressive, often bilateral, sensironeural hearing loss that occurs over weeks to months, generally resulting in significant auditory disability. Response to treatment with immunomodulators other than corticosteroids has been poor. Data from a guinea pig model of AIED and a recent open label trial of etanercept suggested potential treatment benefit. Based on these preliminary results, we conducted a pilot placebo controlled trial of etanercept in AIED patients.
Twenty AIED patients were enrolled in a 12-week blinded placebo (PLA) controlled randomized clinical trial of etanercept (ETA) with 25 mg SC twice weekly. Patients received treatment for 8 weeks with a 4-week follow-up off-treatment. The primary study endpoint was an improvement in pure tone threshold (PTA) of 10 Db in two consecutive frequencies and/or improvement in speech discrimination of >12% at week 8.
Patient demographics were similar for the ETA and PLA patients. Seventeen subjects (8 ETA, 9 PLA) completed the trial. The 3 dropouts were due to lack of efficacy. One ETA and 2 PLA subjects achieved the primary endpoint (p > 0.999). One ETA and 1 PLA pt demonstrated improved in hearing loss and vertigo severity by VAS and hearing disability. No safety issues were observed.
The results of this pilot trial demonstrate that etanercept 25 mg twice weekly for 8 weeks was no better than placebo for treatment of AIED in this patient population.
自身免疫性内耳疾病(AIED)是一种特发性进行性疾病,通常为双侧性,在数周或数月内发生感音神经性听力损失,一般会导致严重的听觉残疾。除皮质类固醇外,免疫调节剂治疗的反应较差。来自AIED豚鼠模型和近期依那西普开放标签试验的数据提示了潜在的治疗益处。基于这些初步结果,我们对AIED患者进行了依那西普的安慰剂对照试验。
20例AIED患者参加了一项为期12周的依那西普(ETA)双盲安慰剂(PLA)对照随机临床试验,皮下注射25mg,每周两次。患者接受8周治疗,停药随访4周。主要研究终点是在第8周时两个连续频率的纯音阈值(PTA)改善10dB和/或言语辨别力改善>12%。
ETA组和PLA组患者的人口统计学特征相似。17名受试者(8名ETA组,9名PLA组)完成了试验。3名退出者是由于缺乏疗效。1名ETA组和2名PLA组受试者达到主要终点(p>0.999)。1名ETA组和1名PLA组患者通过视觉模拟评分法(VAS)显示听力损失和眩晕严重程度有所改善,听力残疾情况也有所改善。未观察到安全问题。
该试验结果表明,对于该患者群体,每周两次、每次25mg依那西普治疗8周并不比安慰剂治疗AIED效果更好。