Coll J, Porta M, Rubiés-Prat J, Gutiérrez-Cebollada J, Tomás S
Department of Medicine, Hospital del Mar, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, Spain.
Ann Rheum Dis. 1992 May;51(5):607-10. doi: 10.1136/ard.51.5.607.
One hundred and forty two patients (62 with definite Sjögren's syndrome, 24 with probable Sjögren's syndrome, and 56 in whom Sjögren's syndrome was finally ruled out) were studied. Schirmer's test and rose bengal staining for the diagnosis of keratoconjunctivitis sicca and salivary scintigraphy and a labial biopsy sample for the diagnosis of xerostomaia were studied in all patients. Rose bengal staining showed high specificity (98%) but low sensitivity (55%). All patients with positive rose bengal staining results had associated xerostomia. In the rose bengal staining positive patients, scintigraphy had 100% specificity. A labial biopsy sample showed high sensitivity in the rose bengal staining, salivary scintigraphy positive group, and high specificity in the rose bengal staining positive, salivary scintigraphy negative group. In patients with negative rose bengal staining, salivary scintigraphy showed 96% specificity and 36% sensitivity. A labial biopsy sample had a sensitivity and specificity greater than 90% in rose bengal staining negative patients. Only 29 biopsy samples were needed to achieve a diagnosis of Sjögren's syndrome in 142 patients (20%). Hence the suggested approach may make it unnecessary to take biopsy samples in approximately 80% of patients with suspected Sjögren's syndrome. Using the stepwise approach of first rose bengal staining, then salivary scintigraphy, and eventually a labial biopsy sample in patients with suspected Sjögren's syndrome, the diagnosis is relatively simple.
对142例患者进行了研究(其中62例为确诊干燥综合征,24例为可能的干燥综合征,56例最终排除干燥综合征)。对所有患者均进行了用于诊断干眼症的泪液分泌试验和孟加拉玫瑰红染色、用于诊断口干症的唾液闪烁显像以及唇腺活检样本检查。孟加拉玫瑰红染色显示特异性高(98%)但敏感性低(55%)。所有孟加拉玫瑰红染色结果阳性的患者均伴有口干症。在孟加拉玫瑰红染色阳性的患者中,闪烁显像的特异性为100%。唇腺活检样本在孟加拉玫瑰红染色、唾液闪烁显像阳性组中显示出高敏感性,在孟加拉玫瑰红染色阳性、唾液闪烁显像阴性组中显示出高特异性。在孟加拉玫瑰红染色阴性的患者中,唾液闪烁显像的特异性为96%,敏感性为36%。唇腺活检样本在孟加拉玫瑰红染色阴性的患者中敏感性和特异性均大于90%。在142例患者(20%)中,仅需29份活检样本即可确诊干燥综合征。因此,所建议的方法可能使约80%疑似干燥综合征的患者无需进行活检样本采集。对疑似干燥综合征的患者采用先进行孟加拉玫瑰红染色、再进行唾液闪烁显像、最终进行唇腺活检样本的逐步方法,诊断相对简单。