Sack Alexander T, Kohler Axel, Linden David E J, Goebel Rainer, Muckli Lars
Department of Neurocognition, Faculty of Psychology, Maastricht University, PO Box 616, Postbus 616, 6200 MD Maastricht, The Netherlands.
Neuroimage. 2006 Feb 15;29(4):1326-35. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2005.08.027. Epub 2005 Sep 26.
Functional imaging has demonstrated the specific involvement of the human middle-temporal complex (hMT/V5+) during processing of moving stimuli. Some studies applied transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) to investigate the causal relevance of hMT/V5+ for motion perception. Although the studies used similar visual stimuli and TMS parameters, the critical time point of functionally relevant hMT/V5+ activity differed by 100 ms and more. The present study aimed to elucidate further the temporal characteristics of motion processing in hMT/V5+ by investigating all critical time windows currently debated in the literature. In contrast to previous studies, we used TMS neuronavigation based on individual fMRI results of five participants to target hMT/V5+, applying single-pulse TMS at 24 different time windows (-50 till +200 ms relative to stimulus onset). We revealed that TMS significantly impaired motion perception when applied over hMT/V5+ at 40 to 30 ms before as well as 130 to 150 ms after onset of the moving stimuli. While the late effective time window conforms to results from previous experiments, we did not find evidence for an early time window around 0 ms that has been reported in other studies. Our neuronavigation approach enabled us to quantify the interindividual variance in the exact location of hMT/V5+ and the respective TMS target position on the skull of the participants. Considering that shifting the TMS coil position only by a few millimeters can already lead to a complete loss of TMS effects, our study clearly demonstrates the utility of neuronavigated TMS when investigating specific neuronal effects as in the case of motion processing.
功能成像已证明人类颞中复合体(hMT/V5+)在运动刺激处理过程中会有特定参与。一些研究应用经颅磁刺激(TMS)来探究hMT/V5+对运动感知的因果相关性。尽管这些研究使用了相似的视觉刺激和TMS参数,但功能相关的hMT/V5+活动的关键时间点相差100毫秒甚至更多。本研究旨在通过调查文献中目前争论的所有关键时间窗,进一步阐明hMT/V5+中运动处理的时间特征。与之前的研究不同,我们基于五名参与者的个体功能磁共振成像(fMRI)结果,使用TMS神经导航来靶向hMT/V5+,在24个不同的时间窗(相对于刺激开始时间为-50至+200毫秒)施加单脉冲TMS。我们发现,在运动刺激开始前40至30毫秒以及开始后130至150毫秒对hMT/V5+施加TMS时,会显著损害运动感知。虽然较晚的有效时间窗与之前实验的结果一致,但我们没有找到其他研究中报道的在0毫秒左右的早期时间窗的证据。我们的神经导航方法使我们能够量化hMT/V5+的确切位置以及参与者颅骨上相应TMS靶点位置的个体间差异。考虑到仅将TMS线圈位置移动几毫米就可能导致TMS效应完全丧失,我们的研究清楚地证明了在研究如运动处理这种特定神经元效应时,神经导航TMS的实用性。