Neutel C Ineke
Treatment and Outcomes Monitoring Section, Centre for Chronic Diseases Prevention and Control, Public Health Agency of Canada, 120 Colonnade Road, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
Int Rev Psychiatry. 2005 Jun;17(3):189-97. doi: 10.1080/09540260500071863.
Recommendations for benzodiazepine (BZD) use suggest durations of no more than a few weeks, but studies report use for months, years, or even decades. This article examines the who (who are long-term users), why (why do they use BZD), what (what are patterns of long-term use) and how (how do they compare to all BZD users). The study population is from the National Population Health Survey in Canada which interviewed respondents four times at two-year intervals, asking about specific drugs use as well as demographic, lifestyle and health-related questions. Long-term BZD use was defined as BZD use for two successive cycles. Four percent of the Canadian population used BZD at any one time, half of whom also reported use in the previous cycle. Benzodiazepine users were more likely to be female, elderly, smokers, to prefer speaking a language other than English, to have insurance coverage for medication, and to have completed high school education. Almost none of these determinants predicted long-term use. Persons reporting BZD use in 2000 had an odds ratio (OR) of 38.6 for also using BZD in 1998, were more likely to use antidepressants (OR=8.5) and suffer from conditions such as poor health, stress, and pain. Most of these determinants had no association with long-term use or if they did at a considerably lower OR. Of the 395 BZD users in 2000, almost 48.4% also used BZD in the previous cycle and 17% in all three previous cycles. Benzodiazepine use in any previous cycle made BZD use in 2000 more likely, with use determined by how recent and the frequency of reported use, culminating in a very high OR of 83.3 for use in all three previous cycles. Continued use for any of the individual BZD tended to be largely for the same BZD. We conclude that: (1) the overriding determinant for BZD use was that of previous use; and (2) long-term use was not determined by the same factors as overall use, which is significant in developing approaches to dealing with long-term BZD use.
关于苯二氮䓬类药物(BZD)使用的建议表明使用时长不应超过几周,但研究报告显示其使用时长可达数月、数年甚至数十年。本文探讨了长期使用者是谁、为何使用BZD、长期使用模式是怎样的以及与所有BZD使用者相比情况如何。研究人群来自加拿大全国人口健康调查,该调查每隔两年对受访者进行四次访谈,询问其特定药物使用情况以及人口统计学、生活方式和健康相关问题。长期使用BZD被定义为连续两个周期使用BZD。4%的加拿大人口在任何时候使用BZD,其中一半还报告在前一个周期也有使用。苯二氮䓬类药物使用者更可能为女性、老年人、吸烟者,更倾向于说英语以外的语言,有药物保险,且完成了高中学业。几乎这些决定因素都无法预测长期使用情况。在2000年报告使用BZD的人在1998年也使用BZD的比值比(OR)为38.6,更可能使用抗抑郁药(OR = 8.5),并患有健康状况不佳、压力和疼痛等疾病。这些决定因素大多与长期使用无关,或者即便有关其比值比也低得多。在2000年的395名BZD使用者中,近48.4%在前一个周期也使用BZD,17%在之前的三个周期都使用。之前任何一个周期使用过BZD都会使在2000年使用BZD的可能性增加,其使用情况取决于报告使用的时间远近和频率,在前三个周期都使用的比值比高达83.3。对于任何一种单独的BZD,持续使用往往主要是同一种BZD。我们得出结论:(1)使用BZD的首要决定因素是之前的使用情况;(2)长期使用并非由与总体使用相同的因素决定,这对于制定应对长期使用BZD的方法具有重要意义。