Di Mario Mario, Fraracci Lucio
Servizio di Radiologia, Ospedale Fondazione Santa Lucia IRCCS, Rome.
Radiol Med. 2005 Sep;110(3):273-9.
The study was undertaken to define some measurements on sagittal MR images that could provide quantitative data on the subacromial space in patients affected by nonspecific impingement syndrome and to correlate these measurements with the Bigliani classification of acromial morphology.
We retrospectively reviewed 74 shoulders in 74 patients (47 males, 27 females, age range 35-62 years) who presented with mechanical disability and pain. The patients underwent MRI using T1-weighted sagittal oblique and coronal SE sequences (TR 500 ms ,TE 12 ms) and T2-weighted FSE sequences (TR 3500, TE 25 ms) with dedicated coil. Two parameters were evaluated: the intrinsec acromial angle and the acromio-humeral distance. The measurements were made on the sagittal images at the acromion-clavicular junction and correlated to the Bigliani classification of acromial morphology. The images were evaluated by two radiologists blinded to the patients' identity, history and arthroscopic results.
The acromial angle was measured in 72 shoulders. The values were found to correlate with the Bigliani classification. In our series, the intrinsic acromial angle (resulting from the intersection between the longitudinal acromial axis and the tangent to the acromial undersurface) ranged from 0 degrees to 17 degrees. In shoulders with rotator cuff tears the acromial angle varied between 8 degrees and 17 degrees. There were no tears for acromial angles below 8 degrees, whereas in patients with full-thickness tears the angles ranged from a minimum of 12 degrees to a maximum of 15 degrees. Acromio-humeral distance ranged from 2 mm to 10 mm; in patients with cuff tears it could not be assessed as it was close to zero in nearly all cases, whereas in cases of impingement without cuff tear it ranged from 5 mm to 10 mm. Impingement without cuff tear was detected in 31 cases, with angles ranging from 10 degrees to 17 degrees.
Our findings demonstrate the effectiveness of the two quantitative parameters (intrinsic acromial angle and acromio-humeral distance) which are important causative factors in impingement syndrome. These parameters were found to be consistent and comparable with the Bigliani classification of acromial morphology which, although providing useful qualitative data, does not fully respond to our quantitative needs. Our study suggests that impingement syndrome is negatively correlated to acromio-humeral distance and positively correlated to intrinsic acromial angle. These parameters, which are readily detected with MRI, may be used by the radiologist and orthopaedic surgeon to screen patients with nonspecific impingement syndrome.
本研究旨在确定矢状面磁共振成像(MR)上的一些测量方法,这些方法可为非特异性撞击综合征患者的肩峰下间隙提供定量数据,并将这些测量结果与肩峰形态的比利亚尼分类法相关联。
我们回顾性分析了74例患者(47例男性,27例女性,年龄范围35 - 62岁)的74个肩部,这些患者均有机械性残疾和疼痛症状。患者使用专用线圈,采用T1加权矢状斜位和冠状面自旋回波(SE)序列(TR 500 ms,TE 12 ms)以及T2加权快速自旋回波(FSE)序列(TR 3500,TE 25 ms)进行MRI检查。评估了两个参数:肩峰固有角和肩峰 - 肱骨距离。测量在肩锁关节处的矢状面上进行,并与肩峰形态的比利亚尼分类法相关联。图像由两位对患者身份、病史和关节镜检查结果不知情的放射科医生进行评估。
对72个肩部测量了肩峰角。发现这些值与比利亚尼分类法相关。在我们的研究系列中,肩峰固有角(由肩峰纵轴与肩峰下表面切线的交点形成)范围为0度至17度。在伴有肩袖撕裂的肩部,肩峰角在8度至17度之间变化。肩峰角低于8度时无撕裂,而在全层撕裂的患者中,角度范围为最小12度至最大15度。肩峰 - 肱骨距离范围为2毫米至10毫米;在伴有肩袖撕裂的患者中,由于几乎所有病例中该距离都接近零,因此无法评估,而在无肩袖撕裂的撞击病例中,其范围为5毫米至10毫米。在31例病例中检测到无肩袖撕裂的撞击,角度范围为10度至17度。
我们的研究结果表明了两个定量参数(肩峰固有角和肩峰 - 肱骨距离)的有效性,它们是撞击综合征的重要致病因素。发现这些参数与肩峰形态的比利亚尼分类法一致且具有可比性,比利亚尼分类法虽然提供了有用的定性数据,但不能完全满足我们的定量需求。我们的研究表明,撞击综合征与肩峰 - 肱骨距离呈负相关,与肩峰固有角呈正相关。这些通过MRI易于检测的参数,可供放射科医生和骨科医生用于筛查非特异性撞击综合征患者。