Anand A, Negi S, Khokhar S, Kumar H, Gupta S K, Murthy G V S, Sharma T K
Dr RP Centre for Ophthalmic Sciences, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi 110029, India.
Eye (Lond). 2007 Jan;21(1):40-5. doi: 10.1038/sj.eye.6702114. Epub 2005 Sep 30.
The lack of prospective data comparing early surgery and medical management in primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG) in the developing world led us to conduct a small randomised controlled clinical trial to evaluate acceptance and effectiveness of early trabeculectomy in these patients.
A total of 60 patients with moderately advanced POAG were randomised into three groups (Group I-Conventional medical management, Group II-Option for early trabeculectomy, Group III-Received an educational package about their disease before an option for early trabeculectomy). The patients were followed up for a period of 6 months for visual acuity, intraocular pressures (IOP), and subjective satisfaction.
The three study groups were statistically similar with respect to mean IOP, demographic, and socio-economic profile. 35% of the patients accepted early surgery when offered a choice between early surgery and medical management in one of the groups. 65% of patients in another group expressed willingness for an early surgery after receiving health education on glaucoma. The mean IOP in the operated eyes was lower than the medically treated eyes at 2 weeks (16.6 vs 23.0 mmHg), 6 months (18.5 vs 22.8 mmHg), and 1-year review (17.9 vs 22.3 mmHg) (P<0.001). No significant difference was seen among the groups with regard to visual acuity and subjective satisfaction.
There is a reasonable acceptance of early surgery in POAG patients in the developing world and increases on educating patients about their disease. Early surgery offers better IOP control with no long-term subjective adverse effects.
在发展中国家,缺乏关于原发性开角型青光眼(POAG)早期手术与药物治疗对比的前瞻性数据,这促使我们开展一项小型随机对照临床试验,以评估这些患者对早期小梁切除术的接受度和有效性。
总共60例中度晚期POAG患者被随机分为三组(第一组 - 传统药物治疗,第二组 - 早期小梁切除术选择组,第三组 - 在有早期小梁切除术选择之前接受关于其疾病的教育包)。对患者进行为期6个月的随访,观察视力、眼压(IOP)和主观满意度。
三个研究组在平均眼压、人口统计学和社会经济状况方面在统计学上相似。在其中一组中,当在早期手术和药物治疗之间进行选择时,35%的患者接受了早期手术。在另一组中,65%的患者在接受青光眼健康教育后表示愿意接受早期手术。术后2周(16.6 vs 23.0 mmHg)、6个月(18.5 vs 22.8 mmHg)和1年复查时,手术眼的平均眼压低于药物治疗眼(P<0.001)。在视力和主观满意度方面,各组之间未观察到显著差异。
在发展中国家,POAG患者对早期手术有合理的接受度,并且在对患者进行疾病教育后接受度有所提高。早期手术能更好地控制眼压,且无长期主观不良反应。