Saygi S, Katz A, Marks D A, Spencer S S
Department of Neurology, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, CT 06510.
Neurology. 1992 Jul;42(7):1274-7. doi: 10.1212/wnl.42.7.1274.
Of all partial seizures, those of frontal lobe origin (FLPS) are most bizarre and are often mistaken for psychogenic seizures (PS). The reverse can also be true. To clarify the confusing clinical presentation of these different seizure types, we compared the clinical ictal characteristics of 63 FLPS in 11 patients with 29 PS in 12 patients. Patients with PS had significantly later age at onset and longer ictal duration. There was no statistically significant difference between the two groups with respect to history of psychiatric disorder, ictal pelvic thrusting, rocking of body, side-to-side head movements, or rapid postictal recovery, all of which previously have been reported as characteristic features of PS. Turning to a prone position during the seizure occurred only in FLPS. Nocturnal occurrence, short ictal duration, younger age at onset, stereotyped patterns of movements, and MRI and EEG abnormality suggested FLPS.
在所有部分性癫痫发作中,额叶起源的癫痫发作(FLPS)最为怪异,常被误诊为心因性癫痫发作(PS)。反之亦然。为了阐明这些不同癫痫发作类型令人困惑的临床表现,我们比较了11例患者的63次FLPS与12例患者的29次PS的发作期临床特征。PS患者的起病年龄显著更晚,发作持续时间更长。两组在精神疾病史、发作期骨盆前推、身体摇晃、头部左右移动或发作后快速恢复方面无统计学显著差异,所有这些此前都被报道为PS的特征性表现。癫痫发作时转为俯卧位仅见于FLPS。夜间发作、发作持续时间短、起病年龄小、刻板的运动模式以及MRI和脑电图异常提示为FLPS。