Hambrecht M, Maurer K, Häfner H
Schizophrenia Research Unit, Central Institute of Mental Health, Mannheim, FRG.
Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol. 1992 May;27(3):117-21. doi: 10.1007/BF00788756.
As part of a systematic research project on the influence of gender factors on age at onset, symptomatology, and course of schizophrenia, data on gender differences in age at onset and symptomatology of schizophrenia from the WHO Collaborative Study "On Assessment and Reduction of Psychiatric Disability" were compared between seven research centres of three different cultural regions. Results on age at onset of five European centres confirmed the well known fact of an earlier onset in men. The earlier onset in women seen in Khartoum and Ankara could be attributed to patient selection because male/female differences in age at onset and male/female ratios in the various samples covary. In the Islamic centres no relevant gender differences in real age at onset and in symptomatology could be detected as probable causes of earlier hospitalisation of women. Major gender differences in symptomatology were found in the Balkan centres of Sofia and Zagreb with a high prevalence of delusional symptoms in women and depression in men. In Western Europe centres, nuclear schizophrenic symptoms were equally prevalent in either sex, while nonspecific symptoms like irritability and tiredness (more frequent in women) and maladaptive illness behaviours like alcohol abuse and social withdrawal (more frequent in men) differed between the sexes. Explanatory hypotheses and the implications of these results are discussed.
作为一项关于性别因素对精神分裂症发病年龄、症状学及病程影响的系统研究项目的一部分,来自三个不同文化区域的七个研究中心对世界卫生组织“精神残疾评估与减少”合作研究中精神分裂症发病年龄和症状学方面的性别差异数据进行了比较。五个欧洲中心关于发病年龄的结果证实了男性发病较早这一众所周知的事实。喀土穆和安卡拉女性发病较早的情况可归因于患者选择,因为发病年龄的男女差异以及各个样本中的男女比例是共同变化的。在伊斯兰中心,未发现发病实际年龄和症状学方面存在相关性别差异,而这可能是女性更早住院的原因。在索非亚和萨格勒布的巴尔干中心发现了症状学方面的主要性别差异,女性妄想症状患病率高,男性则以抑郁为主。在西欧中心,核心精神分裂症症状在男女中同样普遍,而诸如易激惹和疲倦等非特异性症状(女性更常见)以及诸如酒精滥用和社交退缩等适应不良的疾病行为(男性更常见)在性别之间存在差异。文中讨论了解释性假设以及这些结果的意义。