Mellor A C, Dorman M L, Girdler N M
School of Dentistry, The University of Manchester, Manchester, UK.
Int Endod J. 2005 Nov;38(11):789-92; discussion 792-4. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2591.2005.01015_1.x.
To examine whether an intra-oral injection of a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (ketorolac), in association with conventional local anaesthetic techniques, would improve the pulp extirpation rate in teeth with irreversible pulpitis.
A two group double-blind clinical trial was undertaken in the Dental Casualty Department of the University of Manchester School of Dentistry. Patients were randomly allocated to either the test or control group. The test group received an intra-oral injection of ketorolac (30 mg in 1 mL) in the buccal sulcus adjacent to the tooth being treated. After an interval of 15 min, they then received 2.2 mL of 2% lidocaine with 1 : 80 000 epinephrine by buccal infiltration in the maxilla or by inferior dental block in the mandible. The control group received an intra-oral injection of normal saline (1 mL) in the buccal sulcus adjacent to the tooth being treated, followed by the same local anaesthetic regime as the test group after the 15 min interval. Fifteen minutes after the local anaesthetic injections, pulp extirpation was attempted. All patients completed the short-form McGill pain questionnaire prior to treatment and completed identical questionnaires at 6 and 24 h after treatment.
The study protocol set the number of patients to be treated at twenty. However, as the study progressed it became apparent that the intra-oral injection of ketorolac caused significant pain to four of the five patients who received it; therefore the study was terminated after ten patients had been treated. The results from the patients treated showed no significant difference in the pulp extirpation rate between the test and control groups. However, patients with higher pain scores at baseline were less likely to have the pulp completely extirpated, irrespective of whether they were in the test or control group. Pain scores for all patients decreased significantly from baseline to 24 h.
An intra-oral injection of ketorolac did not improve the pulp extirpation rate in a small group of patients with irreversible pulpitis compared with a placebo. In addition, it was associated with such significant pain on injection that it cannot be recommended as a treatment in this situation.
研究在常规局部麻醉技术基础上,口腔内注射非甾体抗炎药(酮咯酸)是否能提高不可逆性牙髓炎患牙的牙髓摘除率。
在曼彻斯特大学牙科学院口腔急诊部进行了一项两组双盲临床试验。患者被随机分配到试验组或对照组。试验组在治疗牙齿相邻的颊沟内口腔注射酮咯酸(30毫克溶于1毫升)。间隔15分钟后,在上颌通过颊部浸润或在下颌通过下牙槽神经阻滞给予2.2毫升含1:80000肾上腺素的2%利多卡因。对照组在治疗牙齿相邻的颊沟内口腔注射生理盐水(1毫升),15分钟间隔后采用与试验组相同的局部麻醉方案。局部麻醉注射15分钟后,尝试进行牙髓摘除。所有患者在治疗前完成简式麦吉尔疼痛问卷,并在治疗后6小时和24小时完成相同问卷。
研究方案设定治疗患者数量为20例。然而,随着研究进展,发现接受酮咯酸口腔注射的5例患者中有4例出现明显疼痛;因此,在治疗10例患者后研究终止。已治疗患者的结果显示,试验组和对照组的牙髓摘除率无显著差异。然而,无论在试验组还是对照组,基线疼痛评分较高的患者牙髓完全摘除的可能性较小。所有患者的疼痛评分从基线到24小时均显著降低。
与安慰剂相比,口腔内注射酮咯酸并未提高一小部分不可逆性牙髓炎患者的牙髓摘除率。此外,注射时伴有明显疼痛,因此在这种情况下不推荐作为一种治疗方法。