Gaia Bruno Felipe, Perella Andréia, de Cara Ana Cláudia Ballet, Antunes José Leopoldo Ferreira, Cavalcanti Marcelo Gusmão Paraiso
Department of Social Dentistry, School of Dentistry, University of São Paulo.
Braz Oral Res. 2005 Jan-Mar;19(1):58-62. doi: 10.1590/s1806-83242005000100011.
The aim of this study was to evaluate the accuracy and reproducibility of computed tomography (CT) image interpretation made in axial slices (2D-CT) and 3D reconstructed images (3D-CT) of patients with craniofacial anomalies. The analyses were made by undergraduate dental students, and compared with the diagnoses considered upon surgical intervention. Computed tomography of 43 patients were analyzed independently by three calibrated examiners (undergraduate students) with, respectively, one, two, and three semesters of experience in craniofacial CT training and interpretation. The analysis of 2D-CT and 3D-CT images were performed at distinct times using an independent workstation associated with a specific computer graphics software for volumetric images. The analysis of inter-examiner agreement and of the agreement between observers and the gold standard was performed using the Kappa test. The accuracy evaluation presented a progressively higher value for examiners with progressively broader experience in 2D-CT and 3D-CT image interpretation. 3D-CT analyses allowed a higher inter-examiner agreement (1 - 0.896) than 2D-CT analyses (1 - 0.614). 3D-CT was considered more precise and accurate than 2D-CT for all students' evaluations. The reproducibility and accuracy varied according to the experience in CT interpretation, and the most experienced student achieved results closer to the gold standard.
本研究的目的是评估对头面部畸形患者进行轴向切片计算机断层扫描(CT)图像(二维CT)和三维重建图像(三维CT)解读的准确性和可重复性。分析由牙科专业本科生进行,并与手术干预时所考虑的诊断结果进行比较。43例患者的CT扫描图像由三名经过校准的检查者(本科生)独立分析,他们分别具有一、二和三个学期的头面部CT培训及解读经验。二维CT和三维CT图像的分析在不同时间使用与特定容积图像计算机图形软件相关联的独立工作站进行。使用Kappa检验对检查者间的一致性以及观察者与金标准之间的一致性进行分析。对于在二维CT和三维CT图像解读方面经验逐渐丰富的检查者,准确性评估呈现出逐渐升高的值。三维CT分析的检查者间一致性(1 - 0.896)高于二维CT分析(1 - 0.614)。在所有学生的评估中,三维CT被认为比二维CT更精确、准确。可重复性和准确性因CT解读经验而异,经验最丰富的学生所取得的结果更接近金标准。