Porter Geoffrey A, Inglis Karen M, Wood Lori A, Veugelers Paul J
Department of Surgery, Dalhousie University, 7-007 Victoria Building, QEII Health Sciences Center, 1278 Tower Road, Halifax, Nova Scotia B3H 2Y9, Canada.
World J Surg. 2005 Nov;29(11):1444-51. doi: 10.1007/s00268-005-7955-1.
This study described the various components of access to care for resectable colorectal cancer, and correlated the timeliness of these components with patient satisfaction. With a prospective/retrospective cohort design, all patients undergoing surgical resection for primary colorectal cancer from 2/1/01 to 15/12/01, were identified during their admission for surgery. A comprehensive, standardized method of ascertaining specific time intervals, which included a patient interview, was used. A patient satisfaction questionnaire was developed, tested, and used in consenting patients. Over the study period, 118 patients underwent colorectal cancer resection. Of these, 110 (93%) consented to participate and 101 (86%) completed the satisfaction questionnaire, including test-retest. The median time intervals (interquartile range) for the various components of access to care were as follows: symptoms to first physician visit, 32 days (10-75); first physician visit to diagnosis, 88 days (44-218); diagnosis to surgery, 19 days (10-44); surgery to chemotherapy (where applicable), 54 days (47-72). On multivariate analysis, tumor location in the rectum was associated with longer prediagnosis intervals, whereas increasing tumor stage was associated with shorter intervals from diagnosis to surgery. Variation in the time interval from diagnosis to surgery was associated with patient satisfaction (r = 0.49; P < 0.0001). Substantially less correlation was identified between patient satisfaction and the time from first physician visit to diagnosis (r = 0.25, P = 0.04). No significant correlation was identified between patient satisfaction scores and the time interval from symptoms to first physician visit (r = 0.11; P = 0.7). Despite concerns regarding surgical waitlists, the longest time intervals experienced by colorectal cancer patients precede diagnosis. However, variations in the relatively short time period from diagnosis to surgery appeared to have the most impact on patient satisfaction. Interventions which improve the timeliness of specific components of access to care may not necessarily result in improved patient satisfaction.
本研究描述了可切除结直肠癌患者获得医疗服务的各个环节,并将这些环节的及时性与患者满意度进行了关联。采用前瞻性/回顾性队列设计,确定了2001年2月1日至2001年12月15日期间因原发性结直肠癌接受手术切除的所有患者,这些患者在入院手术时被纳入研究。采用了一种全面、标准化的方法来确定特定的时间间隔,包括对患者进行访谈。开发、测试并在同意参与的患者中使用了患者满意度调查问卷。在研究期间,118例患者接受了结直肠癌切除术。其中,110例(93%)同意参与,101例(86%)完成了满意度调查问卷,包括重测。获得医疗服务各个环节时间间隔的中位数(四分位间距)如下:出现症状至首次就诊,32天(10 - 75天);首次就诊至确诊,88天(44 - 218天);确诊至手术,19天(10 - 44天);手术至化疗(如适用),54天(47 - 72天)。多因素分析显示,肿瘤位于直肠与确诊前间隔时间较长相关,而肿瘤分期增加与确诊至手术间隔时间较短相关。确诊至手术时间间隔的差异与患者满意度相关(r = 0.49;P < 0.0001)。患者满意度与首次就诊至确诊时间的相关性明显较低(r = 0.25,P = 0.04)。患者满意度评分与出现症状至首次就诊时间间隔之间未发现显著相关性(r = 0.11;P = 0.7)。尽管对手术等候名单存在担忧,但结直肠癌患者经历的最长时间间隔出现在确诊之前。然而,确诊至手术这一相对较短时间段的差异似乎对患者满意度影响最大。改善获得医疗服务特定环节及时性的干预措施不一定会提高患者满意度。