Watmough Shaun A, Aherne Julian, Alewell Christine, Arp Paul, Bailey Scott, Clair Tom, Dillon Peter, Duchesne Louis, Eimers Catherine, Fernandez Ivan, Foster Neil, Larssen Thorjorn, Miller Eric, Mitchell Myron, Page Stephen
Environmental and Resource Studies, Trent University, Peterborough, Ontario, Canada.
Environ Monit Assess. 2005 Oct;109(1-3):1-36. doi: 10.1007/s10661-005-4336-z.
To assess the concern over declining base cation levels in forest soils caused by acid deposition, input-output budgets (1990s average) for sulphate (SO(4)), inorganic nitrogen (NO(3)-N; NH(4)-N), calcium (Ca), magnesium (Mg) and potassium (K) were synthesised for 21 forested catchments from 17 regions in Canada, the United States and Europe. Trend analysis was conducted on monthly ion concentrations in deposition and runoff when more than 9 years of data were available (14 regions, 17 sites). Annual average SO(4) deposition during the 1990s ranged between 7.3 and 28.4 kg ha(-1) per year, and inorganic nitrogen (N) deposition was between 2.8 and 13.8 kg ha(-1) per year, of which 41-67% was nitrate (NO(3)-N). Over the period of record, SO(4) concentration in deposition decreased in 13/14 (13 out of 14 total) regions and SO(4) in runoff decreased at 14/17 catchments. In contrast, NO(3)-N concentrations in deposition decreased in only 1/14 regions, while NH(4)-N concentration patterns varied; increasing at 3/14 regions and decreasing at 2/14 regions. Nitrate concentrations in runoff decreased at 4/17 catchments and increased at only 1 site, whereas runoff levels of NH(4)-N increased at 5/17 catchments. Decreasing trends in deposition were also recorded for Ca, Mg, and K at many of the catchments and on an equivalent basis, accounted for up to 131% (median 22%) of the decrease in acid anion deposition. Base cation concentrations in streams generally declined over time, with significant decreases in Ca, Mg and K occurring at 8, 9 and 7 of 17 sites respectively, which accounted for up to 133% (median 48%) of the decrease in acid anion concentration. Sulphate export exceeded input at 18/21 catchments, likely due to dry deposition and/or internal sources. The majority of N in deposition (31-100%; median 94%) was retained in the catchments, although there was a tendency for greater NO(3)-N leaching at sites receiving higher (<7 kg ha(-1) per year) bulk inorganic N deposition. Mass balance calculations show that export of Ca and Mg in runoff exceeds input at all 21 catchments, but K export only exceeds input at 16/21 sites. Estimates of base cation weathering were available for 18 sites. When included in the mass balance calculation, Ca, Mg and K exports exceeded inputs at 14, 10 and 2 sites respectively. Annual Ca and Mg losses represent appreciable proportions of the current exchangeable soil Ca and Mg pools, although losses at some of the sites likely occur from weathering reactions beneath the rooting zone and there is considerable uncertainty associated with mineral weathering estimates. Critical loads for sulphur (S) and N, using a critical base cation to aluminium ratio of 10 in soil solution, are currently exceeded at 7 of the 18 sites with base cation weathering estimates. Despite reductions in SO(4) and H(+) deposition, mass balance estimates indicate that acid deposition continues to acidify soils in many regions with losses of Ca and Mg of primary concern.
为评估酸沉降导致森林土壤中碱性阳离子水平下降所引发的关注,我们汇总了加拿大、美国和欧洲17个地区21个森林集水区的硫酸盐(SO₄)、无机氮(NO₃-N;NH₄-N)、钙(Ca)、镁(Mg)和钾(K)的输入-输出预算(20世纪90年代平均值)。当有超过9年的数据可用时(14个地区,17个站点),对沉积和径流中的月离子浓度进行了趋势分析。20世纪90年代的年均SO₄沉积量在每年7.3至28.4千克每公顷之间,无机氮(N)沉积量在每年2.8至13.8千克每公顷之间,其中41%-67%为硝酸盐(NO₃-N)。在有记录的时间段内,14个地区中有13个地区的沉积中SO₄浓度下降,17个集水区中有14个集水区的径流中SO₄浓度下降。相比之下,沉积中的NO₃-N浓度仅在1/14的地区下降,而NH₄-N浓度模式各不相同;在3/14的地区上升,在2/14的地区下降。径流中的硝酸盐浓度在17个集水区中有4个下降,仅在1个站点上升,而NH₄-N的径流水平在17个集水区中有5个上升。许多集水区的Ca、Mg和K的沉积也呈现下降趋势,按同等基础计算,占酸根阴离子沉积下降量的比例高达131%(中位数为22%)。溪流中的碱性阳离子浓度一般随时间下降,17个站点中分别有8个、9个和7个站点的Ca、Mg和K显著下降,占酸根阴离子浓度下降量的比例高达133%(中位数为48%)。18/21的集水区中硫酸盐输出量超过输入量,这可能是由于干沉降和/或内部来源。沉积中的大部分N(31%-100%;中位数为94%)保留在集水区中,尽管在接受较高(每年<7千克每公顷)大量无机N沉积的站点,NO₃-N淋溶有增加的趋势。质量平衡计算表明,21个集水区中径流中Ca和Mg的输出量均超过输入量,但K的输出量仅在16/21的站点超过输入量。有18个站点可获得碱性阳离子风化的估计值。当纳入质量平衡计算时,Ca、Mg和K的输出量分别在14个、10个和2个站点超过输入量。每年Ca和Mg的损失占当前可交换土壤Ca和Mg库的相当比例,尽管一些站点的损失可能发生在根区以下的风化反应中,并且与矿物风化估计相关存在相当大的不确定性。在有碱性阳离子风化估计值的18个站点中,目前有7个站点超过了使用土壤溶液中碱性阳离子与铝的临界比值为10的硫(S)和N的临界负荷。尽管SO₄和H⁺沉积有所减少,但质量平衡估计表明,酸沉降在许多地区继续使土壤酸化,Ca和Mg的损失是主要关注点。