Stevens Jeffrey R, Rosati Alexandra G, Ross Kathryn R, Hauser Marc D
Department of Psychology, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138, USA.
Curr Biol. 2005 Oct 25;15(20):1855-60. doi: 10.1016/j.cub.2005.09.016.
Nonhuman animals steeply discount the future, showing a preference for small, immediate over large, delayed rewards. Currently unclear is whether discounting functions depend on context. Here, we examine the effects of spatial context on discounting in cotton-top tamarins (Saguinus oedipus) and common marmosets (Callithrix jacchus), species known to differ in temporal discounting. We presented subjects with a choice between small, nearby rewards and large, distant rewards. Tamarins traveled farther for the large reward than marmosets, attending to the ratio of reward differences rather than their absolute values. This species difference contrasts with performance on a temporal task in which marmosets waited longer than tamarins for the large reward. These comparative data indicate that context influences choice behavior, with the strongest effect seen in marmosets who discounted more steeply over space than over time. These findings parallel details of each species' feeding ecology. Tamarins range over large distances and feed primarily on insects, which requires using quick, impulsive action. Marmosets range over shorter distances than tamarins and feed primarily on tree exudates, a clumped resource that requires patience to wait for sap to exude. These results show that discounting functions are context specific, shaped by a history of ecological pressures.
非人类动物对未来的折扣率很高,表现出对小的即时奖励而非大的延迟奖励的偏好。目前尚不清楚折扣函数是否取决于环境。在这里,我们研究了空间环境对棉顶狨猴(Saguinus oedipus)和普通狨猴(Callithrix jacchus)折扣行为的影响,这两个物种在时间折扣方面存在差异。我们让受试者在小的近在咫尺的奖励和大的远在远处的奖励之间进行选择。狨猴为了获得大的奖励比普通狨猴走得更远,它们关注奖励差异的比例而非绝对值。这种物种差异与在时间任务中的表现形成对比,在时间任务中普通狨猴比狨猴等待大奖励的时间更长。这些比较数据表明环境会影响选择行为,在普通狨猴中这种影响最为明显,它们在空间上的折扣率比在时间上的折扣率更高。这些发现与每个物种的觅食生态细节相呼应。狨猴活动范围广,主要以昆虫为食,这需要迅速、冲动的行动。普通狨猴的活动范围比狨猴小,主要以树液为食,树液是一种聚集性资源,需要耐心等待树液渗出。这些结果表明折扣函数是特定于环境的,由生态压力的历史塑造而成。