Bottini G, Paulesu E, Gandola M, Loffredo S, Scarpa P, Sterzi R, Santilli I, Defanti C A, Scialfa G, Fazio F, Vallar G
Psychology Department, University of Pavia, 27100 Pavia, Italy.
Neurology. 2005 Oct 25;65(8):1278-83. doi: 10.1212/01.wnl.0000182398.14088.e8.
Left caloric vestibular stimulation (CVS) transiently reduces impairments of right-brain-damaged patients with left unilateral neglect, including left hemianesthesia, contralateral to the side of the lesion (contralesional). Conversely, no effect on right contralesional hemianesthesia in left-brain-damaged patients is seen with right CVS. This discrepancy is unexplained.
The authors explored the effect of CVS on right- and left-brain-damaged patients with hemianesthesia. One left-brain-damaged patient had an fMRI study during tactile stimulation before and after left CVS. The same fMRI touch study, without CVS, was performed in neurologically unimpaired subjects.
A transient remission of right hemianesthesia associated with left brain damage was observed, provided that cold CVS was administered to the left ear. In the left-brain-damaged patient studied with fMRI, left CVS modulated the neural response to right hand tactile stimuli of a portion of the secondary somatosensory area (SII) of the right hemisphere. In neurologically unimpaired subjects, fMRI scans showed that the same part of area SII in the right hemisphere was activated by ipsilateral right-sided touches and to a larger extent than area SII in the left hemisphere by left-sided touches.
Left caloric vestibular stimulation is effective on both left and right hemianesthesia because it modulates the hemisphere that has a more complete representation of, or is capable to attend to, the whole somatosensory surface of the body. These results suggest a hardwired hemispheric asymmetry in hand representation, starting from a somatotopically organized brain region such as area SII.
左侧冷热水前庭刺激(CVS)可短暂减轻右侧脑损伤伴左侧单侧空间忽视患者的损伤,包括左侧偏身感觉丧失,即与病变侧(对侧)相对的一侧。相反,右侧CVS对左侧脑损伤患者的右侧对侧偏身感觉丧失没有影响。这种差异尚无法解释。
作者探讨了CVS对患有偏身感觉丧失的右脑和左脑损伤患者的影响。一名左脑损伤患者在左侧CVS前后进行触觉刺激时接受了功能磁共振成像(fMRI)研究。在神经功能正常的受试者中进行了相同的fMRI触觉研究,但未进行CVS。
如果向左耳施加冷CVS,观察到与左脑损伤相关的右侧偏身感觉丧失的短暂缓解。在用fMRI研究的左脑损伤患者中,左侧CVS调节了右半球部分次级体感区(SII)对右手触觉刺激的神经反应。在神经功能正常的受试者中,fMRI扫描显示,右半球SII的同一部分被同侧右侧触摸激活,并且比左半球SII被左侧触摸激活的程度更大。
左侧冷热水前庭刺激对左侧和右侧偏身感觉丧失均有效,因为它调节了对身体整个体感表面具有更完整表征或能够关注的半球。这些结果表明,从诸如SII区这样的按躯体定位组织的脑区开始,手部表征存在硬连线的半球不对称性。