Kavanagh Justin J, Morrison Steven, James Daniel A, Barrett Rod
School of Physiotherapy and Exercise Science, Griffith University, PMB 50 Gold Coast Mail Centre 9726, Gold Coast, Queensland, Australia.
J Biomech. 2006;39(15):2863-72. doi: 10.1016/j.jbiomech.2005.09.012. Epub 2005 Oct 25.
The purpose of this study was to determine the inter- and intra-examiner reliability, and stride-to-stride reliability, of an accelerometer-based gait analysis system which measured 3D accelerations of the upper and lower body during self-selected slow, preferred and fast walking speeds. Eight subjects attended two testing sessions in which accelerometers were attached to the head, neck, lower trunk, and right shank. In the initial testing session, two different examiners attached the accelerometers and performed the same testing procedures. A single examiner repeated the procedure in a subsequent testing session. All data were collected using a new wireless gait analysis system, which features near real-time data transmission via a Bluetooth network. Reliability for each testing condition (4 locations, 3 directions, 3 speeds) was quantified using a waveform similarity statistic known as the coefficient of multiple determination (CMD). CMD's ranged from 0.60 to 0.98 across all test conditions and were not significantly different for inter-examiner (0.86), intra-examiner (0.87), and stride-to-stride reliability (0.86). The highest repeatability for the effect of location, direction and walking speed were for the shank segment (0.94), the vertical direction (0.91) and the fast walking speed (0.91), respectively. Overall, these results indicate that a high degree of waveform repeatability was obtained using a new gait system under test-retest conditions involving single and dual examiners. Furthermore, differences in acceleration waveform repeatability associated with the reapplication of accelerometers were small in relation to normal motor variability.
本研究的目的是确定一种基于加速度计的步态分析系统在自我选择的慢、正常和快步行走速度下测量上半身和下半身三维加速度时的检查者间和检查者内可靠性,以及步幅间可靠性。八名受试者参加了两次测试,在测试中加速度计分别连接到头部、颈部、下躯干和右小腿。在初次测试中,两名不同的检查者连接加速度计并执行相同的测试程序。在随后的测试中,由一名检查者重复该程序。所有数据均使用一种新的无线步态分析系统收集,该系统具有通过蓝牙网络进行近实时数据传输的功能。使用一种称为多重判定系数(CMD)的波形相似性统计量对每个测试条件(4个位置、3个方向、3种速度)的可靠性进行量化。在所有测试条件下,CMD的范围为0.60至0.98,检查者间(0.86)、检查者内(0.87)和步幅间可靠性(0.86)之间无显著差异。小腿节段(0.94)、垂直方向(0.91)和快步行走速度(0.91)在位置、方向和行走速度影响方面的重复性最高。总体而言,这些结果表明,在涉及单检查者和双检查者的重测条件下,使用新的步态系统可获得高度的波形重复性。此外,与加速度计重新应用相关的加速度波形重复性差异相对于正常运动变异性较小。