Han Euna, Liu Gordon G
Department of Health Policy and Administration, School of Public Health, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, 1103A McGavran-Greenberg Hall, CBZ7411, Chapel Hill, NC 27599-7411, USA.
J Ment Health Policy Econ. 2005 Sep;8(3):131-43.
Racial minorities are a rapidly growing portion of the US population. Research suggests that racial minorities are more vulnerable to mental illness due to risk factors, such as higher rates of poverty. Given that the burden of mental illnesses is significant, equal likelihood of mental health services utilization is important to reduce such burden. Racial minorities have been known to use mental health services less than Whites. However, it is unclear whether racial disparity in prescription drug use for mental illnesses exists in a nationally representative sample. For a valid estimation of prescription drug use patterns, the characteristic in the distribution of prescription drug use should be accounted for in the estimation model.
This study is intended to document whether there was a disparity in psychiatric drug use in both extensive and intensive margins between Whites and three racial minorities: Blacks, Hispanics, and Asian-Indians. The study looked at several specified mental illnesses, controlling for underlying health status and other confounding factors.
Secondary data analysis was conducted using the multiyear Medical Expenditure Panel Survey (MEPS), a nationally representative panel sample from 1996 through 2000. This analysis provides estimates of the actual expenditure on prescription drug use for people with specified mental illnesses for this study, based on comparison of Whites and other racial minorities. We derived the estimates from the two-part model, a framework that adjusts the likelihood of using prescription drugs for the specified mental illnesses while estimating the total actual expenditures on prescription drugs among the users.
This study found that Blacks, Hispanics, and Asian-Indians were less likely than Whites to use prescription drugs by 8.3, 6.1 and 23.6 percentage points, respectively, holding other factors constant in the sample, with at least one of the specified mental illnesses. The expenditure on prescription drugs for the specified mental illnesses differs between each of racial minorities (Blacks, Hispanics, and Asian-Indians) and Whites even after adjusting for the different likelihood of using those prescription drugs. Blacks, Hispanics, and Asian-Indians with the specified mental illnesses were estimated to spend 606.53 US dollars, 9.83 US dollars and 179.60 US dollars less per year, respectively, on their actual prescription drugs than Whites.
This study concludes that three racial minorities: Blacks, Hispanics, and Asian-Indians, with the specified mental illnesses are less likely to use psychiatric drugs than Whites. Among users, racial minorities use less psychiatric drugs than Whites in terms of actual spending on those drugs.
There is a need to focus on a program to reach out to racial minorities with a diagnosis of mental illnesses, and this program should consider the cultural specificity of each minority group regarding mental illnesses.
In the development of mental health policy, it is crucial to understand the underlying non-socioeconomic factors which may significantly determine the access to mental health service. Also, education programs or other outreach programs for racial minorities are necessary to understand the different distribution of mental health services for racial minorities.
Future research should examine the causes for racial disparity in the use of prescription drugs for mental illness both in the extensive and intensive margins. An in-depth analysis is needed to map out the attributes for the observed disparity between Whites and racial minorities in mental health service use.
少数族裔在美国人口中所占比例正在迅速增长。研究表明,由于贫困率较高等风险因素,少数族裔更容易患精神疾病。鉴于精神疾病的负担很重,平等利用心理健康服务的可能性对于减轻这种负担很重要。众所周知,少数族裔使用心理健康服务的频率低于白人。然而,在全国代表性样本中,精神疾病处方药使用方面的种族差异是否存在尚不清楚。为了有效估计处方药使用模式,估计模型应考虑处方药使用分布的特征。
本研究旨在记录白人与三个少数族裔(黑人、西班牙裔和亚裔印度人)在精神药物使用的广度和强度方面是否存在差异。该研究考察了几种特定的精神疾病,并控制了潜在的健康状况和其他混杂因素。
使用多年期医疗支出面板调查(MEPS)进行二次数据分析,该调查是1996年至2000年具有全国代表性的面板样本。本分析基于白人与其他少数族裔的比较,提供了本研究中患有特定精神疾病的人群处方药使用实际支出的估计值。我们从两部分模型中得出估计值,该框架在估计使用者中处方药的总实际支出时,调整使用特定精神疾病处方药的可能性。
本研究发现,在样本中其他因素保持不变的情况下,患有至少一种特定精神疾病的黑人、西班牙裔和亚裔印度人使用处方药的可能性分别比白人低8.3、6.1和23.6个百分点。即使在调整了使用这些处方药的不同可能性之后,每个少数族裔(黑人、西班牙裔和亚裔印度人)与白人在特定精神疾病处方药支出方面仍存在差异。估计患有特定精神疾病的黑人、西班牙裔和亚裔印度人每年在实际处方药上的花费分别比白人少606.53美元、9.83美元和179.60美元。
本研究得出结论,患有特定精神疾病的三个少数族裔(黑人、西班牙裔和亚裔印度人)使用精神药物的可能性低于白人。在使用者中,少数族裔在这些药物的实际支出方面使用的精神药物比白人少。
有必要关注一项针对被诊断患有精神疾病的少数族裔的项目,该项目应考虑每个少数族裔群体在精神疾病方面的文化特殊性。
在制定心理健康政策时,了解可能显著决定获得心理健康服务机会的潜在非社会经济因素至关重要。此外,针对少数族裔的教育项目或其他外展项目对于了解少数族裔心理健康服务的不同分布情况是必要的。
未来的研究应在广度和强度方面研究精神疾病处方药使用种族差异的原因。需要进行深入分析,以梳理出白人与少数族裔在心理健康服务使用方面观察到的差异的属性。