Zwisler Ann-Dorthe Olsen, Schou Lone, Soja Anne Merete Boas, Brønnum-Hansen Henrik, Gluud Christian, Iversen Lars, Sigurd Bjarne, Madsen Mette, Fischer-Hansen Jørgen
Department of Cardiology, H:S Bispebjerg Hospital, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Am Heart J. 2005 Nov;150(5):899. doi: 10.1016/j.ahj.2005.06.010.
Current guidelines broadly recommend comprehensive cardiac rehabilitation (CR), although evidence for this is still limited. It is not known whether evidence from before 1995 is still valid.
The DANish Cardiac ReHABilitation (DANREHAB) trial was designed as a centrally randomized clinical trial to clarify whether hospital-based comprehensive CR is superior to usual care for patients with congestive heart failure, ischemic heart disease, or high risk for ischemic heart disease. A combined primary outcome measure included total mortality, myocardial infarction, or readmissions due to heart disease based on linkage to public registries. The CR was an individually tailored, multidisciplinary program (6 weeks of intensive CR and 12 months of follow-up) including patient education, exercise training, dietary counseling, smoking cessation, psychosocial support, risk factor management, and clinical assessment.
Of 5060 discharged patients, 1614 (32%) were eligible for the trial and 770 patients were randomized (47% of those eligible). Participants were younger (P < .001) and had less comorbidity than nonparticipants (P < .03).
Our trial shows that a large-scale, centrally randomized clinical trial on comprehensive CR can be conducted among a broadly defined patient group, but reaching the stipulated number of 1800 patients was difficult. Although the study included relatively many women and older people, elderly patients and patients with high comorbidity were underrepresented, which may influence the external validity.
目前的指南广泛推荐全面心脏康复(CR),尽管相关证据仍然有限。尚不清楚1995年以前的证据是否仍然有效。
丹麦心脏康复(DANREHAB)试验设计为一项集中随机临床试验,以阐明基于医院的全面CR对于充血性心力衰竭、缺血性心脏病或缺血性心脏病高风险患者是否优于常规治疗。综合主要结局指标包括基于与公共登记处的数据关联得出的全因死亡率、心肌梗死或因心脏病再次入院情况。CR是一个个性化的多学科项目(6周强化CR和12个月随访),包括患者教育、运动训练、饮食咨询、戒烟、心理社会支持、危险因素管理和临床评估。
在5060名出院患者中,1614名(32%)符合试验条件,770名患者被随机分组(占符合条件者的47%)。参与者比未参与者更年轻(P < .001)且合并症更少(P < .03)。
我们的试验表明,可以在广泛定义的患者群体中开展关于全面CR的大规模集中随机临床试验,但达到规定的1800名患者数量很困难。尽管该研究纳入了相对较多的女性和老年人,但老年患者和合并症高的患者代表性不足,这可能会影响外部效度。