Bonell Chris, Strange V, Allen E, Barnett-Page E
Public and Environmental Health Research Unit, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, Keppel Street, London WC1E 7HT, UK.
Health Educ Res. 2006 Aug;21(4):452-64. doi: 10.1093/her/cyh071. Epub 2005 Nov 23.
Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) prevention delivered in gay venues in US cities has been found to be effective in reducing HIV transmission in the 1990s but effects might not be generalizable to different times and settings. Doubts have been raised about: outreach's ability to address skills and explore personal behaviour; big-city commercial gay venues being appropriate sites for outreach because of gossip and social surveillance; and acceptability of outreach by professionals rather than 'popular opinion formers'. We evaluated coverage, feasibility, acceptability and perceived impact of venue-based HIV prevention outreach by professionals in London, employing observation, surveys and interviews with venue-users, and focus groups/semi-structured interviews with workers. We found high coverage especially among target groups. Addressing negotiation skills and personal behaviour was feasible but required worker motivation and skill. Social surveillance rarely impeded work. Gay men generally found outreach acceptable and useful, and professionals were not regarded negatively. Impact on knowledge was commonly reported; impacts on negotiation skills and reflection on personal behaviour were more common among men experiencing longer contacts. In conclusion, professional HIV prevention outreach in gay venues in large cities is a feasible and acceptable intervention with significant potential impacts. Workers need to be well briefed and trained to maximize impact.
20世纪90年代,在美国城市的同性恋场所开展的人类免疫缺陷病毒(HIV)预防工作被发现对减少HIV传播有效,但这些效果可能无法推广到不同的时间和环境。人们对以下方面提出了质疑:外展服务解决技能问题和探索个人行为的能力;大城市的商业同性恋场所由于存在流言蜚语和社会监督,是否适合开展外展服务;专业人员而非“舆论引领者”开展外展服务的可接受性。我们通过观察、对场所使用者进行调查和访谈,以及对工作人员进行焦点小组/半结构化访谈,评估了伦敦专业人员在场所开展的HIV预防外展服务的覆盖范围、可行性、可接受性和感知影响。我们发现覆盖率很高,尤其是在目标群体中。解决谈判技巧和个人行为问题是可行的,但需要工作人员的积极性和技能。社会监督很少阻碍工作。男同性恋者普遍认为外展服务是可以接受且有用的,专业人员也没有被负面看待。普遍报告了对外展服务在知识方面的影响;在接触时间较长的男性中,对外展服务在谈判技巧和个人行为反思方面的影响更为常见。总之,在大城市的同性恋场所开展专业的HIV预防外展服务是一种可行且可接受的干预措施,具有显著的潜在影响。工作人员需要接受充分的情况介绍和培训,以最大限度地发挥影响。