Lim Jae-Yol, Choi Jae-Nam, Kim Kwang-Moon, Choi Hong-Shik
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Institute of Logopedics and Phoniatrics, Yongdong Severance Hospital, Yonsei University College of Medicine, Seoul, South Korea.
Acta Otolaryngol. 2006 Jan;126(1):62-9. doi: 10.1080/00016480510043927.
Reinke's edema shows a variety of clinical patterns and differences in voice analysis depending on its type. Electroglottographic measurements help to objectively assess the severity of edema and voice quality before and after surgery.
Reinke's edema manifests various clinical findings and different voice characteristics depending on the degree of swelling and the severity of voice impairment. The aim of this study was to compare the aerodynamic, acoustic and electroglottographic parameters for the different types of Reinke's edema according to its morphological, perceptual and histopathological classifications, and to assess voice quality in patients with Reinke's edema before and after laryngomicrosurgery. We also aimed to determine which parameter was most associated with the improvement in postoperative voice quality and to investigate the clinical usefulness of electroglottographic analysis in Reinke's edema.
The clinical and voice records of 61 patients with Reinke's edema were reviewed. All the patients were classified according to stroboscopic findings (Yonekawa's classification), perceptual grade and histopathological findings. Voice analysis of the perceptual, acoustic, aerodynamic and electroglottographic measurements was carried out using various classifications, and the voices of 23 patients who underwent laryngomicrosurgery were evaluated 2 months after surgery. Furthermore, the voices of 30 normal speakers (controls) were recorded and analyzed.
The fundamental frequency (FxM) of Yonekawa Type III was significantly lower than those of the other types of Reinke's edema, and the SD of the FxM, the percentage irregularity of the FxM (CFx) and the percentage irregularity of the amplitude were larger than those of the other types of Reinke's edema. The closed quotient was significantly higher in Yonekawa Type III. In addition, the mean flow rate (MFR), maximum phonation time and harmonics:noise ratio (HNR) differed significantly among the different types of Reinke's edema. The postoperative results showed an increase in the FxM and an improvement in the MFR, subglottic pressure, shimmer and HNR. Correlation analysis showed that jitter, the HNR, the mean closed quotient and the irregularity of the frequency were the parameters that had the best correlation with improvement in postoperative voice quality.
任克氏水肿根据其类型呈现出多种临床模式及语音分析差异。电子喉镜测量有助于客观评估水肿严重程度以及手术前后的语音质量。
任克氏水肿根据肿胀程度和语音障碍严重程度表现出各种临床发现和不同的语音特征。本研究的目的是根据任克氏水肿的形态学、感知和组织病理学分类,比较不同类型任克氏水肿的空气动力学、声学和电子喉镜参数,并评估喉显微手术前后任克氏水肿患者的语音质量。我们还旨在确定哪个参数与术后语音质量改善最相关,并研究电子喉镜分析在任克氏水肿中的临床实用性。
回顾了61例任克氏水肿患者的临床和语音记录。所有患者根据频闪喉镜检查结果(米川分类法)、感知分级和组织病理学检查结果进行分类。使用各种分类方法对感知、声学、空气动力学和电子喉镜测量进行语音分析,并对23例行喉显微手术的患者术后2个月的语音进行评估。此外,记录并分析了30名正常说话者(对照组)的语音。
米川III型的基频(FxM)显著低于其他类型的任克氏水肿,FxM的标准差、FxM的不规则百分比(CFx)和振幅不规则百分比均大于其他类型的任克氏水肿。米川III型的闭合商显著更高。此外,不同类型的任克氏水肿之间平均流速(MFR)、最大发声时间和谐波:噪声比(HNR)差异显著。术后结果显示FxM增加,MFR、声门下压力、闪烁和HNR有所改善。相关性分析表明,抖动、HNR、平均闭合商和频率不规则性是与术后语音质量改善相关性最好的参数。