Tovey Philip A, Broom Alex F, Chatwin John, Ahmad Salma, Hafeez Muhammad
School of Healthcare, University of Leeds, Leeds, United Kingdom.
Rural Remote Health. 2005 Oct-Dec;5(4):447. Epub 2005 Dec 13.
The healthcare systems of developing countries are complex in that they often accommodate a range of disparate and often competing paradigms of care. This is the case in Pakistan where Indigenous traditional medicine (TM) co-exists with Western allopathic medicine and, in theory at least, with 'globalised' complementary and alternative medicines (CAM). To date we know little about what treatments are being chosen and why in this still predominantly rural country.
To gain a preliminary understanding of patterns of usage of traditional medicine and globalised complementary and alternative medicine by cancer patients in Pakistan.
Structured survey of 362 cancer patients, from diverse regions in the Punjab and North-west Frontier Province provinces, who were being treated in four different hospitals in Lahore, Pakistan.
Use of traditional medicine is high amongst cancer patients, with many patients using a combination of different therapeutic modalities. Unlike studies in Western contexts, this study indicated no relationship between cancer type or sex and use of CAM/TM. However level of education was influential in determining usage of particular TM. There is, however, no uniformity in patterns of use of different TM.
There is less differentiation between social groups in usage of CAM and TM in Pakistan than has been reported in studies of western cancer patients. Differing levels of use for specific TM highlight the need to get beyond monolithic categorizations (such as TM) to understand use patterns for specific indigenous practices (in their social and cultural context).
发展中国家的医疗保健系统很复杂,因为它们常常容纳一系列不同且往往相互竞争的护理模式。巴基斯坦就是这种情况,本土传统医学(TM)与西方对抗疗法医学并存,至少在理论上还与“全球化”的补充和替代医学(CAM)并存。迄今为止,在这个仍以农村为主的国家,我们对人们选择何种治疗方法以及原因知之甚少。
初步了解巴基斯坦癌症患者使用传统医学以及全球化补充和替代医学的模式。
对来自旁遮普省和西北边境省不同地区、在巴基斯坦拉合尔四家不同医院接受治疗的362名癌症患者进行结构化调查。
癌症患者中传统医学的使用率很高,许多患者使用多种不同的治疗方式。与西方背景下的研究不同,本研究表明癌症类型或性别与补充和替代医学/传统医学的使用之间没有关联。然而,教育程度对特定传统医学的使用有影响。不过,不同传统医学的使用模式并不统一。
与西方癌症患者的研究报告相比,巴基斯坦补充和替代医学与传统医学的使用在社会群体之间的差异较小。特定传统医学的不同使用水平凸显了超越单一分类(如传统医学)以了解特定本土疗法(在其社会和文化背景下)使用模式的必要性。