Cudowska B, Kaczmarski M
III Department of Paediatrics, Medical University of Białystok, Poland.
Rocz Akad Med Bialymst. 2005;50:261-7.
Food allergy has been demonstrated to play an important role in the pathogenesis of atopic eczema dermatitis syndrome (AEDS), affecting often atopic infants and young children. The most commonly offending foods are cow's milk, hen's egg, wheat and soy; implicating immediate (IgE-mediated) and late-phase (T-cells) immunological reactions in the pathogenesis of skin lesions. The diagnostic work-up of suspected immediate food reactions includes skin prick tests (SPT) and the measurement of food-specific antibodies (sIgE). The methodology of atopy patch test (APT) has been reported as a diagnostic tool with high predictive capacity for late-phase clinical reactions in children with atopic dermatitis. Although APT has been introduced into the diagnostic procedure for food allergy, its diagnostic accuracy remains still controversial; especially in older children. The aim of study was to evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of the atopy patch test in the detection of food allergy in correlation with SPT, sIgE and positive oral food challenge to milk, in children suffering from AEDS and to assess the sensitivity and specificity of this method in dependence on the age of investigated children.
34 children (25 boys, 9 girls) aged 5 months-16 years with suspicion of milk-related AEDS were investigated. These patients were subdivided into 2 age groups: group A--20 children (<3 years), group B--14 children (>3 years). The diagnostic procedures as skin-prick tests and atopy patch test were performed. The specific IgE to cow's milk allergens were also measured. The open and blind diagnostic oral food challenge were performed to verify the results of tests. Sensitivity, specificity, positive (PPV) and negative (NPV) predictive value of APT were calculated in both age groups.
A positive challenge response to milk was found in 65.0% of investigated children in group A and in 35.7% in group B. No statistical differences in the prevalence of immediate (p<0.1905) and delayed-type (p<0.409) reactions has been found between age groups. Positive APT to milk were noticed in 55.0% of patients in group A and in 35.7% of children from group B, that has been in correlation with positive delayed-type reactions in oral food challenge in 72.7% and 80.0% in corresponding age groups. Polysensitization to other food allergens confirmed by SPT and/or sIgE was detected in 35.0% of patients younger than 3 years of age and in 50.0% of older children. The prevalence of positive APT to other foods (soy, rice, maize, cereals) was significantly higher (p<0.0073) in the polysensitized children from group A. Sensitivity of SPT/sIgE in children with immediate-type reactions to milk was 100%, specificity 94%. Sensitivity of APT to cow's milk in children with late-phase reactions was 80% in both age groups; specificity 70%/89% with comparable PPV in both groups (73%/80%). Parallel skin testing with combined patch test and evaluation of sIgE enhanced the value of sensitivity to 92% in the group A and specificity to 89% in the group B. For PPV corresponding figures were 85%/80%.
APT was found to be more sensitive and specific method than SPT/sIgE in diagnosing delayed food allergy in children with AEDS. No age correlation between positive results of APT and oral food challenge and higher specificity of APT in older children confirm its accuracy in diagnosing delayed cow's milk allergy in all age groups of children. Combined skin prick and patch testing significantly enhances identification of food allergy in children with AEDS. The outcome of the APT with food does not seem to be influenced by age of children, but because of its variability of sensitivity and specificity, a diagnosis of food allergy should be confirmed by oral food challenge.
食物过敏已被证明在特应性皮炎综合征(AEDS)的发病机制中起重要作用,常影响特应性婴幼儿。最常见的致敏食物是牛奶、鸡蛋、小麦和大豆;在皮肤病变的发病机制中涉及速发型(IgE介导)和迟发型(T细胞)免疫反应。疑似速发型食物反应的诊断检查包括皮肤点刺试验(SPT)和食物特异性抗体(sIgE)的检测。已报道特应性斑贴试验(APT)方法作为一种对特应性皮炎患儿迟发型临床反应具有高预测能力的诊断工具。尽管APT已被引入食物过敏的诊断程序,但其诊断准确性仍存在争议;尤其是在大龄儿童中。本研究的目的是评估特应性斑贴试验在检测AEDS患儿食物过敏方面的诊断准确性,并与SPT、sIgE以及牛奶口服食物激发试验阳性结果相关联,同时根据受调查儿童的年龄评估该方法的敏感性和特异性。
对34名年龄在5个月至16岁、疑似与牛奶相关的AEDS患儿进行了研究。这些患者被分为2个年龄组:A组——20名儿童(<3岁),B组——14名儿童(>3岁)。进行了皮肤点刺试验和特应性斑贴试验等诊断程序。还检测了针对牛奶过敏原的特异性IgE。进行了开放和盲法诊断性口服食物激发试验以验证检测结果。计算了两个年龄组中APT的敏感性、特异性、阳性(PPV)和阴性(NPV)预测值。
A组中65.0%的受调查儿童对牛奶激发试验反应阳性,B组中为35.7%。两组之间在速发型反应(p<0.1905)和迟发型反应(p<0.409)的患病率上未发现统计学差异。A组中55.0%的患者和B组中35.7%的儿童对牛奶的APT呈阳性,这与相应年龄组口服食物激发试验中迟发型反应阳性相关,分别为72.7%和80.0%。通过SPT和/或sIgE证实对其他食物过敏原多致敏的情况在3岁以下患者中占35.0%,在大龄儿童中占50.0%。A组多致敏儿童中对其他食物(大豆、大米、玉米、谷物)的APT阳性患病率显著更高(p<0.0073)。对牛奶速发型反应患儿中SPT/sIgE的敏感性为100%,特异性为94%。两个年龄组中对牛奶迟发型反应患儿的APT敏感性均为80%;特异性为70%/89%,两组的PPV相当(73%/80%)。联合斑贴试验和sIgE评估的平行皮肤试验使A组的敏感性值提高到92%,B组的特异性提高到89%。PPV的相应数值为85%/80%。
在诊断AEDS患儿迟发型食物过敏方面,发现APT比SPT/sIgE更敏感和特异。APT阳性结果与口服食物激发试验之间无年龄相关性,且APT在大龄儿童中具有更高的特异性,证实了其在所有年龄组儿童中诊断迟发型牛奶过敏的准确性。联合皮肤点刺和斑贴试验显著提高了AEDS患儿食物过敏的识别率。食物APT的结果似乎不受儿童年龄的影响,但由于其敏感性和特异性的变异性,食物过敏的诊断应通过口服食物激发试验来确认。