Holland Lorne, Bosch Barbara
Department of Pathology, University of Texas Southwestern at Dallas, 75390-9072, USA.
Hum Pathol. 2006 Jan;37(1):1-8. doi: 10.1016/j.humpath.2005.10.004.
To explore the perceptions of medical students regarding pathology and the effect of the sophomore pathology course, a questionnaire was given to second-year students from 5 different medical schools at the beginning and again at the completion of their pathology course. The questionnaire was given to students in the class of 1995 and then again for those in the class of 2002, with nearly 1,500 surveys collected over the study period. The survey included questions that sought to determine students' affinity for pathology, their understanding of the typical duties of a pathologist, and how they viewed pathology relative to other specialties and perceived positives and negatives of being a pathologist. Overall, the second-year pathology course had little effect on medical students' perceptions of pathology but did provide some increase in their understanding of pathology as a profession. Responses were in general stable when comparing the different classes. Those students interested in pathology emphasized the intellectual aspects of pathology although being less deterred by negative factors such as limited patient contact. In our sample of medical schools, the sophomore pathology course was ineffective at influencing students' perceptions of pathology. Furthermore, those students who are interested in pathology are drawn because of a perceived fit between their personalities and the perception of pathology as a solely scholarly and isolated specialty. Better education about the practice of pathology in the second year, and more importantly, continuing into the clinical years, is necessary to combat these misconceptions about pathology.
为了探究医学生对病理学的看法以及大二病理学课程的影响,在病理学课程开始时和结束时,向来自5所不同医学院校的二年级学生发放了问卷。该问卷先发给了1995级的学生,之后又发给了2002级的学生,在研究期间共收集了近1500份调查问卷。调查问题旨在确定学生对病理学的喜爱程度、他们对病理学家典型职责的理解,以及他们如何看待病理学与其他专业的关系,还有对成为病理学家的利弊看法。总体而言,大二病理学课程对医学生对病理学的看法影响甚微,但确实在一定程度上增进了他们对病理学作为一种职业的理解。比较不同班级时,学生的回答总体较为稳定。那些对病理学感兴趣的学生强调病理学的智力层面,尽管较少受到诸如患者接触有限等负面因素的阻碍。在我们的医学院样本中,大二病理学课程在影响学生对病理学的看法方面效果不佳。此外,那些对病理学感兴趣的学生是因为他们认为自己的个性与病理学作为一个纯粹学术性和孤立性专业的认知相契合。有必要在大二时,更重要的是在临床阶段持续进行关于病理学实践的更好教育,以消除对病理学的这些误解。