Staudt Christine Bettina, Krejci Ivo, Mavropoulos Anestis
Division of Orthodontics, University of Geneva, Switzerland.
J Dent. 2006 Aug;34(7):498-502. doi: 10.1016/j.jdent.2005.11.006. Epub 2006 Jan 18.
In order to reduce curing time for bracket bonding with light-cured composites, manufacturers increase the power density (PD) of light sources. The present study aims at investigating the relationship between PD and shear bond strength (SBS) at short exposure time.
Stainless steel brackets were bonded to bovine incisors using light-cured adhesive. Six groups of 20 incisors each were exposed to 4s of halogen light with different PD increasing from 500 to 3000 mW/cm(2) in steps of 500 mW/cm(2). Two more groups were exposed to a PD of 3000 mW/cm(2) for 6s (n=15) and 8s (n=19), thus simulating non-available PD of 4500 and 6000 mW/cm(2) for 4s. A halogen lamp with a PD of 1000 mW/cm(2) was used for 40s in the control group (n=15). After storage for 24h at 37 degrees C in water, SBS and adhesive remnant index (ARI) were recorded.
SBS was significantly different among groups (ANOVA, p<0.001). SBS comparable to the control group could only be achieved with a PD of at least 3000 mW/cm(2). An exponential model described the relationship between SBS and PD. The best-fit curve based on this model reached 85% of the highest possible SBS at approximately 4000 mW/cm(2). ARI scores showed that higher PD was associated with better adhesion at the bracket/adhesive interface.
Our findings show the SBS dependence on PD, and thus provide a valuable tool for the development of light-curing systems. An exponential model suggests that SBS enters a region of saturation and cannot be improved significantly by further increasing PD.
为了缩短光固化复合材料粘结托槽的固化时间,制造商提高了光源的功率密度(PD)。本研究旨在探讨短暴露时间下PD与剪切粘结强度(SBS)之间的关系。
使用光固化粘合剂将不锈钢托槽粘结到牛切牙上。六组,每组20颗切牙,分别暴露于卤素光下4秒,PD从500 mW/cm²以500 mW/cm²的步长递增至3000 mW/cm²。另外两组分别暴露于3000 mW/cm²的PD下6秒(n = 15)和8秒(n = 19),从而模拟无法获得的4500和6000 mW/cm²的PD照射4秒的情况。对照组(n = 15)使用功率密度为1000 mW/cm²的卤素灯照射40秒。在37℃水中储存24小时后,记录SBS和粘结剂残留指数(ARI)。
各组之间的SBS有显著差异(方差分析,p < 0.001)。只有PD至少为3000 mW/cm²时,SBS才能达到与对照组相当的水平。指数模型描述了SBS与PD之间的关系。基于该模型的最佳拟合曲线在约4000 mW/cm²时达到最高可能SBS的85%。ARI评分显示,较高的PD与托槽/粘结剂界面更好的粘结相关。
我们的研究结果表明SBS依赖于PD,从而为光固化系统的开发提供了有价值的工具。指数模型表明SBS进入了一个饱和区域,进一步增加PD不能显著提高SBS。