Kong Xuan, Gozani Shai N, Hayes Michael T, Weinberg David H
NEUROMetrix Inc., 62 Fourth Avenue, Waltham, MA 02451, USA.
Clin Neurophysiol. 2006 Feb;117(2):405-13. doi: 10.1016/j.clinph.2005.10.019. Epub 2006 Jan 3.
This study evaluated validity and reliability of automated median and ulnar sensory nerve conduction study (NCS) measurements by the NC-stat.
Median and ulnar distal sensory latencies (DSL) and amplitudes (SNAP) were measured in sixty subjects with the NC-stat and by a neurologist (reference) using traditional instrumentation. The median-ulnar DSL differences (MUD) was calculated. Validity was quantified by the Pearson correlation. Reliability was evaluated by the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), Bland-Altman analysis, and inter-rater agreement of MUD abnormalities.
As a result of differences in electrode placement, NC-stat and reference mean values had systematic differences. The correlation ranged from 0.70 (ulnar DSL) to 0.91 (median DSL). The ICC ranged from 0.69 (ulnar DSL) to 0.91 (median DSL). In Bland-Altman analysis of DSLs, NC-stat measurements had a bias of 0.56 ms (median) and 0.31 ms (ulnar) and precision of 0.31 and 0.30 ms. Inter-rater agreement for MUD abnormalities was 93.8% (raw) and 0.80 (Kappa).
NC-stat validity and reliability metrics were similar to traditional NCS. Use of the NC-stat would require applicable reference ranges.
NC-stat median and ulnar NCS are valid and reliable. This device may be useful for increasing availability of NCS when clinically appropriate.
本研究评估了NC-stat自动测量正中神经和尺神经感觉神经传导研究(NCS)的有效性和可靠性。
使用NC-stat和神经科医生(作为参考)采用传统仪器对60名受试者测量正中神经和尺神经的远端感觉潜伏期(DSL)及波幅(SNAP)。计算正中神经 - 尺神经DSL差值(MUD)。通过Pearson相关性对有效性进行量化。通过组内相关系数(ICC)、Bland-Altman分析以及MUD异常的评分者间一致性来评估可靠性。
由于电极放置的差异,NC-stat和参考均值存在系统差异。相关性范围从0.70(尺神经DSL)至0.91(正中神经DSL)。ICC范围从0.69(尺神经DSL)至0.91(正中神经DSL)。在DSL的Bland-Altman分析中,NC-stat测量的偏差为0.56 ms(正中神经)和0.31 ms(尺神经),精密度分别为0.31和0.30 ms。MUD异常的评分者间一致性为93.8%(原始数据)和0.80(Kappa值)。
NC-stat的有效性和可靠性指标与传统NCS相似。使用NC-stat需要适用的参考范围。
NC-stat正中神经和尺神经NCS是有效且可靠的。在临床合适时,该设备可能有助于提高NCS的可及性。