In vitro comparison of two techniques for suture prosthesis placement in the muscular process of the equine arytenoid cartilage.

OBJECTIVE

To compare in vitro the load necessary for a partial and complete rupture of the muscular process arytenoid cartilage when a suture prosthesis is positioned by a bone trocar versus a trocar point needle and to compare failure mode.

STUDY DESIGN

Experimental using cadaver specimens.

SAMPLE POPULATION

Larynges from 18 Thoroughbred race horses, aged 2-20 years.

METHODS

Arytenoid cartilages were separated randomly into 2 groups: group 1-suture prosthesis inserted directly through the muscular process using a curved trocar point needle and group 2-suture passed through a hole predrilled with a 3 mm bone trocar. Distracting force (constant rate, 1 mm/s) was applied to the suture until failure of the muscular process. Partial failure load, maximum load at complete failure, and force-time curve were recorded. Each arytenoid cartilage was examined, radiographed, and classified as having a linear or curved failure plane.

RESULTS

No significant differences in mechanical test variables were detected. Failure mode followed the fissures occurring at the beginning of failure and then followed the tension axis. Significantly more linear failures occurred in group 2 (trocar) and more curved failures occurred in group 1 (needle).

CONCLUSION

Use of a bone trocar for tunneling through the muscular process may reduce fissure formation.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Use of bone trocar to create a hole in the muscular process of the arytenoid cartilage for suture passage in laryngoplasty may reduce fissure formation and decrease the risk of cartilage failure from suture pullout.