Tanaka Eiji, Matsumoto Akihiro, Suzuki Fumitaka, Kobayashi Mariko, Mizokami Masashi, Tanaka Yasuhito, Okanoue Takeshi, Minami Masahito, Chayama Kazuaki, Imamura Michio, Yatsuhashi Hiroshi, Nagaoka Shinya, Yotsuyanagi Hiroshi, Kawata Sumio, Kimura Tatsuji, Maki Noboru, Iino Shiro, Kiyosawa Kendo
Department of Medicine, Shinshu University School of Medicine, Matsumoto, Japan.
Liver Int. 2006 Feb;26(1):90-6. doi: 10.1111/j.1478-3231.2005.01200.x.
The clinical usefulness of hepatitis B virus core-related antigen (HBVcrAg) assay was compared with that of HBV DNA assay in predicting the occurrence of lamivudine resistance in patients with chronic hepatitis B.
Of a total of 81 patients who were treated with lamivudine, 25 (31%) developed lamivudine resistance during a median follow-up period of 19.3 months.
The pretreatment positive rate of HBe antigen, or pretreatment levels of HBVcrAg or HBV DNA did not differ between patients with and without lamivudine resistance. Levels of both HBVcrAg and HBV DNA decreased after the initiation of lamivudine administration; however, the level of HBVcrAg decreased significantly more slowly than that of HBV DNA. The occurrence of lamivudine resistance was significantly less frequent in the 56 patients whose HBV DNA level was less than 2.6 log copy/ml at 6 months of treatment than in the remaining 25 patients. The cumulative rate of lamivudine resistance was as high as 70% within 2 years in the latter group, while it was only 28% in the former group. Lamivudine resistance did not occur during the follow-up period in the 19 patients whose HBVcrAg level was less than 4.6 log U/ml at 6 months of treatment, while it did occur in 50% of the remaining patients within 2 years.
These results suggest that measurement of HBV DNA is valuable for identifying patients who are at high risk of developing lamivudine resistance, and that, conversely, measurement of HBVcrAg is valuable for identifying those who are at low risk of lamivudine resistance.
比较乙型肝炎病毒核心相关抗原(HBVcrAg)检测与HBV DNA检测在预测慢性乙型肝炎患者拉米夫定耐药发生情况方面的临床实用性。
共有81例接受拉米夫定治疗的患者,其中25例(31%)在中位随访期19.3个月期间出现拉米夫定耐药。
拉米夫定耐药患者与未耐药患者的HBe抗原预处理阳性率、HBVcrAg或HBV DNA预处理水平无差异。拉米夫定治疗开始后,HBVcrAg和HBV DNA水平均下降;然而,HBVcrAg水平下降明显比HBV DNA慢。治疗6个月时HBV DNA水平低于2.6 log拷贝/ml的56例患者中,拉米夫定耐药的发生率明显低于其余25例患者。后一组患者2年内拉米夫定耐药的累积发生率高达70%,而前一组仅为28%。治疗6个月时HBVcrAg水平低于4.6 log U/ml的19例患者在随访期间未发生拉米夫定耐药,而其余患者中有50%在2年内发生了耐药。
这些结果表明,检测HBV DNA对于识别有拉米夫定耐药高风险的患者有价值,相反,检测HBVcrAg对于识别拉米夫定耐药低风险的患者有价值。