Papanikolaou E G, Camus M, Fatemi H M, Tournaye H, Verheyen G, Van Steirteghem Andre, Devroey Paul
Centre for Reproductive Medicine, University Hospital, Vrije Universtiteit Brussel (Dutch-Speaking Brussels Free University), Laarbeeklaaan 101, B-1090, Brussels, Belgium.
Reprod Biomed Online. 2006 Jan;12(1):60-5. doi: 10.1016/s1472-6483(10)60981-9.
The current study aimed to investigate whether single day-3 embryo transfer (SET) results in higher early pregnancy loss (EPL) than single blastocyst transfer (SBET). A total of 896 patients underwent 1103 IVF cycles with a gonadotrophin-releasing hormone (GnRH) antagonist protocol. In 603 cycles (D3 group) a single embryo on day 3 of the embryo culture was transferred, whereas in the remaining 500 cycles a single blastocyst was transferred on day 5 (D5 group). Multifollicular ovarian stimulation was performed with a GnRH antagonist protocol starting on day 6. SET resulted in 209 pregnancies (34.7%), compared with 221 pregnancies (44.2%) for SBET. Early pregnancy loss rate was significantly higher with SET compared with SBET (26.8% versus 17.2%, P = 0.017) and ongoing implantation rate was also significantly higher with day 5 compared with day-3 embryo transfer (OR:1.68, 95% confidence interval:1.31-2.18). Sub-optimal embryo selection for transfer on day 3, in addition to asynchronization between altered endometrium and early exposure of cleavage-stage embryos, might explain the above difference. Nevertheless, the higher implantation potential of the blastocyst questions the rationale behind performing single embryo transfer on day 3 of embryo culture in women under 36 years old.
本研究旨在调查单胚胎第3天移植(SET)是否比单囊胚移植(SBET)导致更高的早期妊娠丢失(EPL)。共有896例患者接受了1103个采用促性腺激素释放激素(GnRH)拮抗剂方案的体外受精周期。在603个周期(第3天组)中,移植胚胎培养第3天的单个胚胎,而在其余500个周期中,在第5天移植单个囊胚(第5天组)。从第6天开始采用GnRH拮抗剂方案进行多卵泡卵巢刺激。SET导致209例妊娠(34.7%),而SBET导致221例妊娠(44.2%)。与SBET相比,SET的早期妊娠丢失率显著更高(26.8%对17.2%,P = 0.017),并且与胚胎第3天移植相比,第5天的持续着床率也显著更高(比值比:1.68,95%置信区间:1.31 - 2.18)。除了子宫内膜改变与卵裂期胚胎早期暴露之间的不同步之外,第3天移植时胚胎选择欠佳可能解释了上述差异。然而,囊胚更高的着床潜力对36岁以下女性在胚胎培养第3天进行单胚胎移植背后的基本原理提出了质疑。