Sans-Corrales Mireia, Pujol-Ribera Enriqueta, Gené-Badia Joan, Pasarín-Rua Maria Isabel, Iglesias-Pérez Begoña, Casajuana-Brunet Josep
Institut Català de la Salut (ICS), Spain.
Fam Pract. 2006 Jun;23(3):308-16. doi: 10.1093/fampra/cmi112. Epub 2006 Feb 3.
To identify, from a systematic review of the literature, the attributes of Family Medicine (FM) that influence the primary health care outcome as measured by users' satisfaction, improvement in patient health and in costs.
Literature search of Medline and the Cochrane library using MeSH terms 'Primary Health' or 'Family Practice' or 'Family Physicians' and 'Outcome Assessment' or 'Process Assessment'. Papers were excluded if they lacked a based on primary data, if no single component of FM was assessed; if indicators of evaluation were not related to health, satisfaction or costs.
A total of 356 articles were initially identified and 19 finally met the inclusion criteria. Study methods were a systematic review of randomized control trials, a double-blind randomized trial, 4 systematic reviews of observational studies, 2 cohort studies and 12 descriptive cross-sectional studies.
There was evidence of relationships between the attributes of FM and the service outcomes measured by indicators of satisfaction, health and cost. User satisfaction was associated with accessibility, continuity of care, consultation time and the doctor-patient relationship. Improvement in patient's health was related to continuity, consultation time, doctor-patient relationship and the implementation of preventive activities. Coordination of care showed mixed results with health outcomes. Continuity, consultation time, doctor-patient communication and prevention were cost-effective in the primary care setting.
通过对文献的系统综述,确定家庭医学(FM)中影响初级卫生保健结果的属性,这些结果通过用户满意度、患者健康改善情况和成本来衡量。
使用医学主题词“初级卫生保健”或“家庭医疗”或“家庭医生”以及“结果评估”或“过程评估”在Medline和Cochrane图书馆进行文献检索。如果论文缺乏基于原始数据、未评估FM的任何单一组成部分、评估指标与健康、满意度或成本无关,则将其排除。
最初共识别出356篇文章,最终19篇符合纳入标准。研究方法包括对随机对照试验的系统综述、双盲随机试验、4篇观察性研究的系统综述、2篇队列研究和12篇描述性横断面研究。
有证据表明FM的属性与通过满意度、健康和成本指标衡量的服务结果之间存在关联。用户满意度与可及性、连续护理、咨询时间和医患关系相关。患者健康改善与连续性、咨询时间、医患关系以及预防活动的实施有关。护理协调在健康结果方面显示出混合结果。在初级保健环境中,连续性、咨询时间、医患沟通和预防具有成本效益。