Kujan O, Duxbury A J, Glenny A M, Thakker N S, Sloan P
School of Dentistry, The University of Manchester, Manchester, UK.
Oral Dis. 2006 Mar;12(2):194-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1601-0825.2005.01188.x.
To survey two broad areas of oral cancer awareness and management of patients at risk of oral cancer by specialists in oral surgery, oral medicine, surgical dentistry and general dental practitioners (GDPs) in the UK. The first of these included knowledge and awareness of aetiological factors, changing patterns of disease, and screening/detection programmes including their effectiveness. The second included oral cancer detection methods, advice on avoidance of high-risk activity and self-examination, and referral pattern of GDPs.
A pretested, 44-item questionnaire, a covering letter, a brief outline of the research protocol and return, stamped envelope were mailed in March 2003. A sample of 200 GDPs whose names were obtained from the General Dental Council's main list and 305 dental specialist names obtained from specialist's list in surgical dentistry, oral medicine and oral surgery were selected randomly. Information on oral cancer awareness and practice, screening practice and education was obtained.
The response rate was 66.9%. The knowledge of the dental specialists was consistent with that in reports of current aetiological studies on oral cancer. However there were gaps in the GDP's knowledge and ascertainment of oral cancer risk factors. Over 70% of the dental specialists provided counselling advice on the risks of tobacco and alcohol habits compared with 41.2% of GDPs. More GDPs (52.4%) than specialists (35.4%) believed that oral cancer screening on a national basis would be effective in decreasing the mortality of oral cancer. Over 95% of all respondents used a visual examination for oral cancer screening and 89.9% of all respondents strongly believed that visual screening is effective in the early detection of oral cancer.
The results showed that GDPs had knowledge gaps in their awareness of oral cancer risk factors and the application of preventive measures. Most dental health providers in the UK perform visual screening of the oral mucosa for their patients. Opinion was equivocal as to whether a nationally based screening programme similar to cervical cancer would be effective in improving the mortality and morbidity of oral cancer.
调查英国口腔外科、口腔内科、口腔颌面外科专家以及普通牙科医生(GDPs)对口腔癌的认知情况和对口腔癌高危患者的管理情况。其中第一个方面包括对病因学因素的知识和认知、疾病模式的变化以及筛查/检测项目(包括其有效性)。第二个方面包括口腔癌检测方法、关于避免高危行为和自我检查的建议以及普通牙科医生的转诊模式。
2003年3月邮寄了一份经过预测试的、包含44个条目的问卷、一封附信、一份研究方案简要概述以及回邮的贴好邮票的信封。从英国牙科总会的主要名单中随机抽取200名普通牙科医生样本,并从口腔颌面外科、口腔内科和口腔外科的专家名单中随机抽取305名牙科专家样本。获取了有关口腔癌认知与实践、筛查实践及教育方面的信息。
回复率为66.9%。牙科专家的知识与当前口腔癌病因学研究报告中的情况一致。然而,普通牙科医生在口腔癌风险因素的知识和认定方面存在差距。超过70%的牙科专家提供了关于烟草和酒精习惯风险的咨询建议,而普通牙科医生的这一比例为41.2%。认为全国性口腔癌筛查能有效降低口腔癌死亡率的普通牙科医生(52.4%)多于专家(35.4%)。超过95%的所有受访者使用视觉检查进行口腔癌筛查,89.9%的所有受访者坚信视觉筛查对口腔癌的早期检测有效。
结果表明,普通牙科医生在口腔癌风险因素认知及预防措施应用方面存在知识差距。英国大多数牙科保健提供者为患者进行口腔黏膜的视觉筛查。对于类似于宫颈癌的全国性筛查项目是否能有效改善口腔癌的死亡率和发病率,观点不一。