Moreno David, Ferrándiz Lara, Pérez-Bernal Ana M, Ríos Juan J, Carrasco Rafael, Camacho Francisco
Unidad de Lesiones Pigmentadas y Teledermatología, Departamento de Dermatología, Hospital Universitario Virgen Macarena, Avda. Dr. Fedriani 3, 41071 Seville, Spain.
Actas Dermosifiliogr. 2005 May;96(4):222-30. doi: 10.1016/s0001-7310(05)73074-x.
Pigmented lesion clinics (PLC's) were developed as a quick referral system for patients with pigmented lesions. However, the most appropriate method of selecting patients who need to be seen in these units is not clearly defined. Teledermatology is a tool whose usefulness as a patient selection system for PLC's needs to be evaluated.
To evaluate teleconsultation as a screening system for patients with pigmented lesions in terms of efficacy, accuracy and satisfaction.
Teleconsultations received at a PLC over a period of 12 weeks were evaluated. Teleconsultation patients reported changes in a pigmented lesion, a lesion that had recently appeared, multiple lesions, symptomatic lesions or concern about a nevus. We calculated the time intervals in sending the teleconsultation report and in patients being seen at the "physical" PLC consultation, the intraobserver, interobserver and pathologist kappa coefficients, as well as the degree of satisfaction of patients and Primary Care (PC) physicians.
219 teleconsultations were evaluated, 49.3 % of which were referred to the "physical" consultation. The most frequent reason for the teleconsultation was concern about a nevus (37.0 %). The teleconsultations received responses in an average time of 43.9 hours, and patients were seen at the "physical" consultation within 2 weeks. The intraobserver agreement was kappa = 0.93 (95 % CI 0.87-0.98); interobserver agreement, kappa = 0.91 (95 % CI 0.87-0.96); and the agreement between the teledermatologist and the pathologist, kappa = 0.79 (95 % CI 0.70-0.89). 86 % of the patients and 91 % of the Primary Care physicians said that they were "very satisfied" with the implementation of this new system.
Teleconsultation is an accurate screening system for patients with pigmented lesions. With this methodology, waiting times for patients with malignant lesions or those suspected of malignancy can be shortened at the same time as the PLC's excess workload is decreased. However, more experience is needed to establish the true usefulness of this filtering system in the early diagnosis of melanoma.
色素沉着病变诊所(PLC)作为色素沉着病变患者的快速转诊系统而设立。然而,选择需要在这些科室就诊患者的最合适方法尚无明确定义。远程皮肤病学作为一种用于PLC患者选择系统的工具,其效用有待评估。
从有效性、准确性和满意度方面评估远程会诊作为色素沉着病变患者筛查系统的情况。
对PLC在12周内收到的远程会诊进行评估。远程会诊患者报告色素沉着病变有变化、有新出现的病变、有多发性病变、有症状性病变或对痣有担忧。我们计算了发送远程会诊报告与患者在“实体”PLC会诊时就诊之间的时间间隔、观察者内、观察者间以及病理学家的kappa系数,以及患者和初级保健(PC)医生的满意度。
共评估了219次远程会诊,其中49.3%被转诊至“实体”会诊。远程会诊最常见的原因是对痣的担忧(37.0%)。远程会诊平均在43.9小时内得到回复,患者在2周内接受了“实体”会诊。观察者内一致性kappa = 0.93(95%CI 0.87 - 0.98);观察者间一致性kappa = 0.91(95%CI 0.87 - 0.96);远程皮肤科医生与病理学家之间的一致性kappa = 0.79(95%CI 0.70 - 0.89)。86%的患者和91%的初级保健医生表示他们对这一新系统的实施“非常满意”。
远程会诊是色素沉着病变患者的准确筛查系统。通过这种方法,在减少PLC过多工作量的同时,可以缩短恶性病变或疑似恶性病变患者的等待时间。然而,需要更多经验来确定这种筛选系统在黑色素瘤早期诊断中的真正效用。