Bapat Mihir R, Lahiri Vinod J, Harshavardhan N S, Metkar Umesh S, Chaudhary Kshitij C
Orthopaedics, King Edward Memorial Hospital, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India.
Eur Spine J. 2007 Feb;16(2):187-97. doi: 10.1007/s00586-006-0071-6. Epub 2006 Feb 16.
Prospective study of 27 consecutive cases of tuberculous atlanto-axial instability operated between 1998 and 2003. Early surgical stabilization of tuberculous atlanto-axial instability has gained popularity. This is largely due to success of chemotherapy in rapid control of infection. Although selective atlanto-axial fusion techniques are advocated in other indications, their role in tuberculosis remains confined to atlanto-axial wiring techniques that are mechanically unsound. The role of three-point rigid fixation using trans-articular screws (TAS) remains unclear. The objectives of this study are: (1) To define the role of trans-articular screws in tuberculous atlanto-axial instability based on radiological criteria. (2) To attempt to separate patients that can be treated by selective atlanto-axial fixation as against the standard occipito-cervical fusion (OCF). (3) Compare the clinical and radiological outcome parameters between the two groups. Twenty-seven consecutive patients of tuberculous atlanto-axial instability were operated between 1998 and 2003. The pattern of articular surface destruction and the reducibility of the atlanto-axial complex were assessed on plain radiographs and MRI. The reducibility of the C1-C2 joint was graded as reducible, partially reducible and irreducible. Pattern of the C1-C2 articular mass destruction was grouped as minimal, moderate and severe. The patients were divided into two surgical groups based on radiological findings and were treated with TAS (n=11) and OCF (n=16) fusion. The three-point fixation provided by the TAS allowed early brace free mobilization by 3 months with fusion rate of 100%. Fusion occurred in 83.16% in the OCF group. Implant failure occurred in two patients who underwent OCF. The patient satisfaction rate in the TAS group and the OCF group was 90.90 and 62.50%, respectively. Results in 27 consecutive patients demonstrate improved patient fusion and satisfaction rates in the TAS group. Judicious selection of patients for TAS fixation is possible with relatively few complications in tuberculosis of the atlanto-axial complex. This, however, requires a thorough understanding of the MRI pattern of involvement of the atlanto-axial complex that is difficult in non-endemic areas.
对1998年至2003年间连续手术治疗的27例结核性寰枢椎不稳病例的前瞻性研究。结核性寰枢椎不稳的早期手术稳定治疗已越来越普遍。这主要归功于化疗在快速控制感染方面的成功。尽管在其他适应证中提倡选择性寰枢椎融合技术,但它们在结核病中的作用仍局限于机械上不可靠的寰枢椎钢丝技术。经关节螺钉(TAS)三点刚性固定的作用仍不明确。本研究的目的是:(1)根据影像学标准确定经关节螺钉在结核性寰枢椎不稳中的作用。(2)试图区分可通过选择性寰枢椎固定治疗的患者与标准枕颈融合术(OCF)治疗的患者。(3)比较两组的临床和影像学结果参数。1998年至2003年间对27例连续的结核性寰枢椎不稳患者进行了手术。在X线平片和MRI上评估关节面破坏模式和寰枢椎复合体的可复性。C1-C2关节的可复性分为可复性、部分可复性和不可复性。C1-C2关节块破坏模式分为轻度、中度和重度。根据影像学检查结果将患者分为两个手术组,分别采用TAS(n=11)和OCF(n=16)融合术治疗。TAS提供的三点固定使患者在3个月时即可早期无需支具活动,融合率为100%。OCF组的融合率为83.16%。接受OCF治疗的两名患者出现植入物失败。TAS组和OCF组的患者满意率分别为90.90%和62.50%。27例连续患者的结果表明,TAS组患者的融合率和满意率有所提高。对于结核性寰枢椎复合体,明智地选择患者进行TAS固定是可行的,并发症相对较少。然而,这需要对寰枢椎复合体受累的MRI模式有透彻的了解,而这在非流行地区是困难的。