Healton E B, Savage D G, Brust J C, Garrett T J, Lindenbaum J
Department of Neurology, Columbia-Presbyterian Medical Center, New York, NY 10032.
Medicine (Baltimore). 1991 Jul;70(4):229-45. doi: 10.1097/00005792-199107000-00001.
We reviewed 153 episodes of cobalamin deficiency involving the nervous system that occurred in 143 patients seen over a recent 17-year period at 2 New York City hospitals. Pernicious anemia was the most common underlying cause of the deficiency. Neurologic complaints, most commonly paresthesias or ataxia, were the first symptoms of Cbl deficiency in most episodes. The median duration of symptoms before diagnosis and treatment with vitamin B12 was 4 months, although long delays in diagnosis occurred in some patients. Diminished vibratory sensation and proprioception in the lower extremities were the most common objective findings. A wide variety of neurologic symptoms and signs were encountered, however, including ataxia, loss of cutaneous sensation, muscle weakness, diminished or hyperactive reflexes, spasticity, urinary or fecal incontinence, orthostatic hypotension, loss of vision, dementia, psychoses, and disturbances of mood. Multiple neurologic syndromes were often seen in a single patient. In 42 (27.4%) of the 153 episodes, the hematocrit was normal, and in 31 (23.0%), the mean corpuscular volume was normal. Neutropenia and thrombocytopenia were unusual even in anemic patients. In nonanemic patients in whom diagnosis was delayed, neurologic progression frequently occurred although the hematocrit remained normal. In 27 episodes, the serum cobalamin concentration was only moderately decreased (in the range of 100-200 pg/ml) and in 2 the serum level was normal. Neurologic impairment, as assessed by a quantitative severity score, was judged to be mild in 99 episodes, moderate in 39 and severe in 15. Severity of neurologic dysfunction before treatment was clearly related to the duration of symptoms prior to diagnosis. In addition, the hematocrit correlated significantly with severity, independent of the longer duration of symptoms in nonanemic patients. Four patients experienced transient neurologic exacerbations soon after beginning treatment with cyanocobalamin, with subsequent recovery. Followup evaluation was adequate to assess the neurologic response to vitamin B12 therapy in 121 episodes. All patients responded, and in 57 (47.1%), recovery was complete, with no remaining symptoms or findings on examination. The severity score was reduced by 50% or greater after treatment in 91% of the episodes. Residual long-term moderate or severe neurologic disability was noted following only 7 (6.3%) episodes. The extent of neurologic involvement after treatment was strongly related to that before therapy as well as to the duration of symptoms. The percent improvement over baseline neurologic status after treatment was inversely related to duration of symptoms and hematocrit. Some evidence of response was always seen during the first 3 months of treatment.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)
我们回顾了153例发生于神经系统的钴胺素缺乏病例,这些病例来自纽约市两家医院在最近17年期间诊治的143名患者。恶性贫血是该缺乏症最常见的潜在病因。神经学主诉,最常见的是感觉异常或共济失调,在大多数病例中是钴胺素缺乏的首发症状。在诊断并开始用维生素B12治疗之前,症状的中位持续时间为4个月,不过有些患者诊断延误时间很长。下肢振动觉和本体感觉减退是最常见的客观体征。然而,还出现了各种各样的神经学症状和体征,包括共济失调、皮肤感觉丧失、肌肉无力、反射减弱或亢进、痉挛、尿失禁或大便失禁、直立性低血压、视力丧失、痴呆、精神病以及情绪障碍。同一患者常出现多种神经综合征。在153例病例中,42例(27.4%)血细胞比容正常,31例(23.0%)平均红细胞体积正常。即使在贫血患者中,中性粒细胞减少和血小板减少也不常见。在诊断延误的非贫血患者中,尽管血细胞比容仍正常,但神经学症状仍经常进展。在27例病例中,血清钴胺素浓度仅中度降低(在100 - 200 pg/ml范围内),2例血清水平正常。根据定量严重程度评分评估,99例神经学损害为轻度,39例为中度,15例为重度。治疗前神经功能障碍的严重程度与诊断前症状持续时间明显相关。此外,血细胞比容与严重程度显著相关,与非贫血患者较长的症状持续时间无关。4例患者在开始用氰钴胺治疗后不久出现短暂的神经学症状加重,随后恢复。在121例病例中进行了充分的随访评估,以评估对维生素B12治疗的神经学反应。所有患者均有反应,57例(47.1%)完全恢复,检查时无残留症状或体征。91%的病例治疗后严重程度评分降低了50%或更多。仅7例(6.3%)病例出现残留的长期中度或重度神经功能残疾。治疗后神经受累程度与治疗前以及症状持续时间密切相关。治疗后相对于基线神经状态的改善百分比与症状持续时间和血细胞比容呈负相关。在治疗的前3个月内总能见到一些反应迹象。(摘要截选至400字)