Vitaro F, Brendgen M, Pagani L, Tremblay R E, McDuff P
Research Unit on Children's Psycho-Social Maladjustment, University of Montréal, Boul, Quebec, Canada.
Dev Psychopathol. 1999 Spring;11(2):287-304. doi: 10.1017/s0954579499002060.
We tested three competing models regarding the role of deviant friends in the trajectory linking early disruptiveness with later conduct problems through the use of a preventive intervention program. The program was implemented during the second and third grade. One model predicted that the program would positively affect later conduct problems by facilitating nondeviant peer association during early adolescence. The second model predicted a direct impact of the program on later conduct problems through the reduction of early disruptiveness. The third model predicted an interaction between postintervention disruptiveness and association with less deviant friends. The results showed that the program's effects on later conduct problems were mediated by the reduction in disruptiveness and by the association with less deviant friends. However, the positive effect of associating with less deviant friends depended on whether children's disruptiveness had been reduced or not by their participation in the program, thus supporting the third model. We recommend using intervention studies to test developmental models.
我们通过一项预防性干预计划,测试了关于偏差朋友在将早期破坏行为与后期行为问题联系起来的轨迹中所起作用的三种相互竞争的模型。该计划在二年级和三年级实施。一个模型预测,该计划将通过在青春期早期促进非偏差同伴交往,对后期行为问题产生积极影响。第二个模型预测,该计划将通过减少早期破坏行为,对后期行为问题产生直接影响。第三个模型预测,干预后破坏行为与与较少偏差朋友的交往之间存在相互作用。结果表明,该计划对后期行为问题的影响是通过破坏行为的减少以及与较少偏差朋友的交往来介导的。然而,与较少偏差朋友交往的积极效果取决于儿童的破坏行为是否因参与该计划而减少,从而支持了第三个模型。我们建议使用干预研究来测试发展模型。