Bettucci Diego, Testa Lucia, Calzoni Silvia, Mantegazza Paola, Viana Michele, Monaco Francesco
Headache Centre, Department of Neurology, University Amedeo Avogadro, Corso Mazzini 18, I-28100, Novara, Italy.
J Headache Pain. 2006 Feb;7(1):34-6. doi: 10.1007/s10194-005-0251-5. Epub 2005 Dec 15.
Chronic tension type headache (CTTH) has a strong impact on the Quality Of Life (QOL). We carried out an open-label randomized clinical trial on 18 patients with CTTH in order to compare two different regimens of pharmacological prophylaxis: the first provided for the use of amitriptyline 20 mg/d during 3 months, while in the second we combined amitriptyline with tizanidine (4 mg/d) in the first 3 weeks of treatment. Our hypothesis is that the combination therapy may guarantee an improvement of QOL even in the early stages of treatment. In fact, it's as well-known, there is a delay of 2-3 weeks in the prophylactic effect of amitriptyline, with a consequent persistence, in the first phases of therapy, of the headache and its negative impact. We assessed the following outcome measures: frequency, pain intensity, duration of headache and the Headache Impact Test (HIT) score, used as headache-related QOL measure. The combination therapy was effective since the first month of treatment, with a significant reduction of the headache, greater than one obtained with amitriptyline alone, in terms of frequency (-52.3% vs. -40.7%), intensity (-59.51% vs. -20.39%) and duration (-53.17% vs. -36.16%). This trend was confirmed by the HIT. Our data suggest that the combination of tizanidine with amitriptyline is faster than the amitriptyline alone in providing an improvement in the headache pattern and correlated QOL.
慢性紧张型头痛(CTTH)对生活质量(QOL)有严重影响。我们对18例CTTH患者进行了一项开放标签随机临床试验,以比较两种不同的药物预防方案:第一种方案是在3个月内使用20毫克/天的阿米替林,而第二种方案是在治疗的前三周将阿米替林与替扎尼定(4毫克/天)联合使用。我们的假设是,联合治疗即使在治疗早期也可能保证生活质量的改善。事实上,众所周知,阿米替林的预防作用有2至3周的延迟,因此在治疗的第一阶段,头痛及其负面影响会持续存在。我们评估了以下结果指标:头痛频率、疼痛强度、头痛持续时间以及用作与头痛相关的生活质量指标的头痛影响测试(HIT)评分。联合治疗从治疗的第一个月起就有效,在头痛频率(-52.3%对-40.7%)、强度(-59.51%对-20.39%)和持续时间(-53.17%对-36.16%)方面,头痛显著减少,比单独使用阿米替林时更大。HIT证实了这一趋势。我们的数据表明,替扎尼定与阿米替林联合使用在改善头痛模式和相关生活质量方面比单独使用阿米替林更快。