Muraro Giovanni B, Grifoni Riccardo, Spazzafumo Liana
Department of Surgery, INRCA, Ancona, Italy.
Surg Technol Int. 2005;14:222-6.
Many lasers are widely used in urological surgery for several applications. Their use to treat the superficial bladder cancer (SBC) is safe and minimally invasive. The Holmium:YAG (Ho:YAG) laser represents the pinnacle of laser technology in Urology. The authors carried out this study on safety, efficacy, complication rates, postoperative catheterization time, and hospital stay of high-risk patients who underwent Ho:YAG vs. transurethral resection (TUR). Two groups of high-risk patients with SBC and comorbidities underwent either Ho:YAG or TUR. Different clinical aspects of the tumours and recurrences were considered. No significant difference between the two groups was noted regarding number, progression of grade and stage and place and time of recurrences. In the Ho:YAG patients, perioperative complications occurred at a lower percent than in the TUR group. Also, in 54% of patients, the catheter was removed within 24 hours; 76% had a postoperative hospital stay of 24 to 48 hours. In the TUR patients: 4% had the catheter removed within 24 hours and 6% left the hospital within 24 to 48 hours. In SBC treatment, Ho:YAG and TUR were equally as effective; the Ho:YAG laser was associated with shorter catheterization time and hospital stay. These Ho:YAG features could be advantageous from a psychological standpoint, particularly for elderly, high-risk patients and in terms of cost:benefit ratios.
许多激光在泌尿外科手术中有多种应用,被广泛使用。其用于治疗浅表性膀胱癌(SBC)安全且微创。钬激光(Ho:YAG)代表了泌尿外科激光技术的巅峰。作者对接受Ho:YAG治疗与经尿道切除术(TUR)的高危患者的安全性、有效性、并发症发生率、术后导尿时间和住院时间进行了这项研究。两组患有SBC和合并症的高危患者分别接受了Ho:YAG或TUR治疗。考虑了肿瘤和复发的不同临床方面。两组在复发的数量、分级和分期进展以及复发部位和时间方面均未发现显著差异。在Ho:YAG组患者中,围手术期并发症的发生率低于TUR组。此外,54%的患者在24小时内拔除了导尿管;76%的患者术后住院时间为24至48小时。在TUR组患者中:4%的患者在24小时内拔除了导尿管,6%的患者在24至48小时内出院。在SBC治疗中,Ho:YAG和TUR同样有效;Ho:YAG激光与更短的导尿时间和住院时间相关。从心理角度来看,尤其是对于老年高危患者以及从成本效益比方面考虑,Ho:YAG的这些特点可能具有优势。