Rio E, Bardet E, Ferron C, Peuvrel P, Supiot S, Campion L, Beauvillain De Montreuil C, Mahe M-A, Dreno B
Service de radiothérapie, CRLCC Nantes-Atlantique, 44000 Nantes, France.
Cancer Radiother. 2006 May;10(3):101-6. doi: 10.1016/j.canrad.2006.01.005. Epub 2006 Mar 10.
Purpose. - To analyse outcomes after interstitial brachytherapy of facial periorificial skin carcinomas. Patients and methods. - We performed a retrospective analysis of 97 skin carcinomas (88 basal cell carcinomas (BCCs), 9 squamous cell carcinomas (SCCs)) of the nose, periorbital areas and ears from 40 previously untreated patients (group 1) and 57 patients who had undergone surgery (group 2). The average dose was 55 Gy [50-65] in group 1 and 52 Gy [50-60] in group 2 (mean implantation times: 79 and 74 hours respectively). We calculated survival rates and assessed functional and cosmetic results de visu. Results. - Median age was 71 years [17-97]. There were 29 T1, 8 T2, 1 T3 and 2 Tx tumors in group 1. Tumors were<2 cm in group 2. Local control was 92.5% in group 1 and 88% in group 2 (median follow-up: 55 months [6-132]). Five-year disease-free survival was better in group 1 (91% [75-97]) than in group 2 (80% [62-90]), P=0.23. Of the 34 patients whose results were re-assessed, eight presented pruritus or epiphora. One group 2 patient had an impaired eyelid aperture. Cosmetic results were better in group 1 than in group 2, with respectively 72% (8/11) vs 52% (12/23) of good results and 28 (3/11) vs. 43% (10/23) of fair results. Conclusion. - Brachytherapy provided a high level of local control and good cosmetic results for facial periorificial skin carcinomas that pose problems of surgical reconstruction. Results were better for untreated tumors than for incompletely excised tumors or tumors recurring after surgery.
目的。——分析面部口周皮肤癌间质近距离放射治疗后的结果。患者与方法。——我们对40例未经治疗的患者(第1组)和57例接受过手术的患者(第2组)的97例鼻、眶周区域和耳部皮肤癌(88例基底细胞癌(BCC),9例鳞状细胞癌(SCC))进行了回顾性分析。第1组的平均剂量为55 Gy [50 - 65],第2组为52 Gy [50 - 60](平均植入时间分别为79小时和74小时)。我们计算了生存率,并直观地评估了功能和美容效果。结果。——中位年龄为71岁[17 - 97]。第1组有29例T1、8例T2、1例T3和2例Tx肿瘤。第2组肿瘤<2 cm。第1组的局部控制率为92.5%,第2组为88%(中位随访时间:55个月[6 - 132])。第1组的5年无病生存率(91% [75 - 97])优于第2组(80% [62 - 90]),P = 0.23。在34例结果被重新评估的患者中,8例出现瘙痒或溢泪。第2组有1例患者睑裂受损。第1组的美容效果优于第2组,良好效果分别为72%(8/11)对52%(12/23),一般效果分别为28%(3/11)对43%(10/23)。结论。——近距离放射治疗为存在手术重建问题的面部口周皮肤癌提供了高水平的局部控制和良好的美容效果。未经治疗的肿瘤比不完全切除的肿瘤或术后复发的肿瘤效果更好。