Nilsen Per, Hudson Diana, Lindqvist Kent
Dept. of Health and Society, Div. of Social Medicine and Public Health Science, Linköping University, SE 581-83 Linköping, Sweden.
Int J Inj Contr Saf Promot. 2006 Mar;13(1):7-13. doi: 10.1080/17457300500167651.
Injuries pose an economic problem of immense proportion to communities in every society. The economic burden from injuries can be quantified through cost-of-injury studies, using techniques adopted from cost-of-illness research. This study explores the feasibility of applying results and methodologies from existing cost-of-injury studies in economic analyses of injury prevention interventions and programmes. The literature on cost-of-injury studies and economic appraisals of injury prevention efforts was examined to elicit studies that calculated injury costs. Studies were accepted for inclusion if they included an analysis of the costs of all injuries occurring in a geographical area (community, region or country) during a specific time period, employed a societal perspective and an incidence-based costing approach and were conducted in industrialized countries. There were 12 studies that met the inclusion criteria. The average total cost per injury case was USD $3536, while the average share of indirect to total cost per injury case was 71%. However, the cost figures showed wide variation across the studies. Based on the limited similarity of findings from the studies, it was concluded that it is not feasible to apply results and methodologies from existing cost-of-injury studies. The cost estimators described in this study could possibly be adapted for use as reference points in economic analyses of existing programmes, but any other uses should be approached with caution. Locally obtained data are needed for reliable economic analyses of injury prevention interventions and programmes.
伤害给每个社会中的社区带来了极其严重的经济问题。伤害造成的经济负担可以通过伤害成本研究来量化,采用的是疾病成本研究中所采用的技术。本研究探讨了将现有伤害成本研究的结果和方法应用于伤害预防干预措施和项目经济分析的可行性。对伤害成本研究和伤害预防工作经济评估的文献进行了审查,以找出计算伤害成本的研究。如果研究包括对特定时间段内在某个地理区域(社区、地区或国家)发生的所有伤害成本的分析,采用社会视角和基于发病率的成本核算方法,并在工业化国家进行,则该研究被纳入。有12项研究符合纳入标准。每个伤害案例的平均总成本为3536美元,而每个伤害案例中间接成本占总成本的平均比例为71%。然而,各项研究中的成本数字差异很大。基于这些研究结果的有限相似性,得出的结论是,应用现有伤害成本研究的结果和方法是不可行的。本研究中描述的成本估算器可能适合用作现有项目经济分析的参考点,但任何其他用途都应谨慎对待。进行伤害预防干预措施和项目可靠的经济分析需要本地获取的数据。