Georgalas Christos, Obholzer Rupert, Martinez-Devesa P, Sandhu G
The Royal National Throat, Nose and Ear Hospital, London, UK.
Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 2006 Mar;88(2):202-6. doi: 10.1308/003588406X95039.
Septal surgery has been identified as suitable for day-surgery, but is not widely performed as such. Guidelines for day-surgery state that the unexpected admission rate should be 2-3%. Previous audits have not achieved this figure and septoplasty is not universally considered suitable for day-surgery. We have reviewed practice over 4 years in our institution to identify surgical and patient factors associated with unexpected admission following septoplasty.
A retrospective case note based audit of day-case septoplasty procedures reviewed at the end of each year between October 1998 and October 2002.
A total of 432 septal surgery procedures were performed, comprising 378 septoplasties and 54 submucous resections. Thirty-eight patients were admitted, overwhelmingly because of haemorrhage in the immediate postoperative period, giving an overall admission rate of 8.8% within the first 24 h. Factors associated strongly with re-admission were the use of intranasal splints, the performance of revision surgery, submucous resection (as opposed to septoplasty) and, less so, the performance of additional procedures and the peri-operative administration of diclofenac. There was no correlation between unexpected admission and grade of surgeon, surgical technique or any of the patient factors analysed.
The unexpected admission rate of septal surgery performed at our unit is above that recommended for day-case procedures, but is within the range previously published. Patient satisfaction with day-case septoplasty has been shown to be high. We believe that septoplasty should be performed in this setting but there is a significant chance that patients may need admission, and a pathway should be in place for this to occur with minimal disruption to the patient.
鼻中隔手术已被认定适合日间手术,但实际开展并不广泛。日间手术指南规定意外住院率应为2%-3%。以往的审计未达到这一数字,鼻中隔成形术也未被普遍认为适合日间手术。我们回顾了本机构4年的手术情况,以确定鼻中隔成形术后意外住院相关的手术及患者因素。
对1998年10月至2002年10月期间每年年底回顾的日间鼻中隔成形术病例记录进行回顾性审计。
共进行了432例鼻中隔手术,包括378例鼻中隔成形术和54例黏膜下切除术。38例患者住院,绝大多数是因为术后即刻出血,术后24小时内总体住院率为8.8%。与再次住院密切相关的因素包括使用鼻内夹板、进行翻修手术、黏膜下切除术(与鼻中隔成形术相对),以及进行额外手术和围手术期使用双氯芬酸的情况相对较少。意外住院与外科医生级别、手术技术或任何分析的患者因素之间均无相关性。
我们单位进行的鼻中隔手术意外住院率高于日间手术推荐率,但在先前公布的范围内。已表明患者对日间鼻中隔成形术的满意度较高。我们认为在这种情况下应进行鼻中隔成形术,但患者很有可能需要住院,应制定相应途径,使住院对患者的干扰降至最低。