Graziano Nicole, McGuire Michael J, Roberson Alan, Adams Craig, Jiang Hua, Blute Nicole
McGuire Malcolm Pirnie, 1855 Blake Street, Suite 101, Denver, Colorado 80202, USA.
Environ Sci Technol. 2006 Feb 15;40(4):1163-71. doi: 10.1021/es051586y.
The goal of this project was to gain a better understanding of atrazine occurrence in the United States by surveying drinking water utilities' sources and finished water for atrazine on a weekly basis for seven months. Atrazine is a contaminant of interest because the United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) has found short-term atrazine exposure above the drinking water maximum contaminant level (MCL) to potentially cause heart, lung, and kidney congestion, low blood pressure, muscle spasms, weight loss, and damage to the adrenal glands. Long-term exposure to atrazine concentrations above the drinking water MCL has been linked to weight loss, cardiovascular damage, retinal and muscle degeneration, and cancer. This survey effort improved upon previously conducted atrazine surveys through intensive, high frequency sampling (participating plants sampled their raw and finished water on a weekly basis for approximately seven months). Such an intensive effort allowed the authors to gain a better understanding of short-term atrazine occurrence and its variability in drinking water sources. This information can benefit the drinking water industry by facilitating (1) better atrazine occurrence management (i.e., awareness when plants may be more susceptible to atrazine), (2) more efficient atrazine control (e.g., effective treatment alternatives and more effective response to atrazine occurrence), and (3) treatment cost reduction (e.g., efficient atrazine control can result in substantial cost savings). Forty-seven drinking watertreatment plants located primarily in the Midwestern United States participated in the survey and sampled their raw and finished water on a weekly basis from March through October. Samples were analyzed using the Abraxis enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) test kit. Confirmation samples for quality assurance/quality control (QA/QC) purposes were analyzed using solid-phase extraction (SPE) followed by gas chromatography mass spectrophotometry (GC/MS). Several important conclusions can be drawn from this study including (1) surface waters were confirmed to be more vulnerable to atrazine contamination than groundwater sources, (2) peak atrazine concentrations corresponded well to precipitation/runoff events, and (3) atrazine occurrence tended to be uniform geographically when compared by river drainage basins. In addition, this project confirmed that the Abraxis atrazine ELISA test kit tended to have a positive bias (i.e., the measured ELISA concentration was higher than the actual concentration) in most measured samples. Finished samples tended to have more of a positive bias than raw water samples. Therefore, this bias may limit the effectiveness for ELISA for regulatory monitoring. There are many other applications for ELISA, however, including frequent monitoring for early detections of atrazine concentration changes that might trigger conventional analysis by GC/MS or be used for activated carbon dosing or other treatment operating controls.
该项目的目标是,通过对饮用水处理厂的水源和成品水进行为期七个月的每周一次的阿特拉津调查,更好地了解美国阿特拉津的存在情况。阿特拉津是一种受关注的污染物,因为美国环境保护局(USEPA)发现,短期接触超过饮用水最大污染物水平(MCL)的阿特拉津可能会导致心脏、肺部和肾脏充血、低血压、肌肉痉挛、体重减轻以及肾上腺损伤。长期接触超过饮用水MCL浓度的阿特拉津与体重减轻、心血管损伤、视网膜和肌肉退化以及癌症有关。这项调查工作通过密集的高频采样(参与调查的工厂每周对其原水和成品水进行采样,为期约七个月)改进了之前进行的阿特拉津调查。这样的密集工作使作者能够更好地了解阿特拉津在饮用水源中的短期存在情况及其变异性。这些信息可通过促进以下方面使饮用水行业受益:(1)更好地管理阿特拉津的存在情况(即了解工厂何时可能更容易受到阿特拉津影响),(2)更有效地控制阿特拉津(例如,有效的处理替代方法以及对阿特拉津出现情况更有效的应对措施),以及(3)降低处理成本(例如,有效的阿特拉津控制可大幅节省成本)。主要位于美国中西部的47家饮用水处理厂参与了此次调查,并在3月至10月期间每周对其原水和成品水进行采样。使用Abraxis酶联免疫吸附测定(ELISA)测试试剂盒对样品进行分析。为质量保证/质量控制(QA/QC)目的而设的确认样品,采用固相萃取(SPE)然后进行气相色谱质谱联用(GC/MS)分析。从这项研究中可以得出几个重要结论,包括:(1)地表水被证实比地下水源更容易受到阿特拉津污染;(2)阿特拉津浓度峰值与降水/径流事件吻合良好;(3)按河流流域比较时,阿特拉津的存在情况在地理上趋于一致。此外,该项目证实,Abraxis阿特拉津ELISA测试试剂盒在大多数测量样品中往往存在正偏差(即测量的ELISA浓度高于实际浓度)。成品水样品的正偏差往往比原水样品更大。因此,这种偏差可能会限制ELISA用于监管监测的有效性。然而,ELISA还有许多其他应用,包括频繁监测以早期发现可能触发GC/MS常规分析的阿特拉津浓度变化,或用于活性炭投加或其他处理操作控制。