Benson C, Docherty D, Brandenburg J
ARC Performance Training Systems, Surrey, BC, Canada.
J Sci Med Sport. 2006 May;9(1-2):135-42. doi: 10.1016/j.jsams.2005.07.001. Epub 2006 Mar 31.
The aim of this study was to compare the acute neuromuscular responses during resistance exercise performed with different loading protocols. Thirteen (N=13) college-aged male subjects experienced in weight training completed two different weight training protocols involving a single elbow flexion exercise. During both protocols subjects performed three sets of the exercise with a 3-min rest between each set. One protocol required the subjects to perform each set to failure using 100% 10 repetition maximum (RM) load whereas the second protocol required the subjects to perform 10 repetitions for the first two sets using 90% 10RM load and only go to failure on the third set. Maximal voluntary isometric contraction (MVIC), integrated EMG recording (iEMG) of the biceps brachii, and blood lactate were measured before and upon completion of the two training protocols. Subjects were able to perform a significantly greater volume of work (total repetitionsxload) in the 90% 10RM protocol compared to the 100% 10RM protocol. Both protocols elicited similar cumulative levels of fatigue as reflected by a decrease in MVIC and iEMG(max) and an increase in blood lactate (p< or =0.05). As a result of the drop in repetitions performed in successive sets, it was concluded that training with 100% 10RM while exercising to failure in each set may not optimise the training volume, which may have implications for chronic muscle adaptation.
本研究的目的是比较采用不同负荷方案进行抗阻训练时的急性神经肌肉反应。13名(N = 13)有重量训练经验的大学年龄男性受试者完成了两种不同的重量训练方案,均包含单一的肘部屈曲练习。在两种方案中,受试者均进行三组该练习,每组之间休息3分钟。一种方案要求受试者使用100%的10次重复最大值(RM)负荷进行每组练习直至力竭,而第二种方案要求受试者前两组使用90%的10RM负荷进行10次重复,仅第三组练习至力竭。在两种训练方案开始前和结束后,测量最大随意等长收缩(MVIC)、肱二头肌的肌电图积分记录(iEMG)以及血乳酸水平。与100%的10RM方案相比,受试者在90%的10RM方案中能够完成显著更多的工作量(总重复次数×负荷)。两种方案引发的疲劳累积水平相似,表现为MVIC和iEMG(最大值)下降以及血乳酸增加(p≤0.05)。由于连续几组练习中重复次数的减少,得出结论:每组练习至力竭的同时采用100%的10RM进行训练可能无法优化训练量,这可能对慢性肌肉适应有影响。