Dabrowska H, Fisher S W, Estenik J, Kidekhel R, Stromberg P
College of Biological Sciences, The Ohio State University, Columbus, USA.
Arch Environ Contam Toxicol. 2006 Aug;51(2):270-86. doi: 10.1007/s00244-005-0113-9. Epub 2006 Mar 30.
Concentrations and profiles of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) were determined in three tissues of adult snapping turtles (Chelydra serpentina serpentina) from six locations in the Ohio Basin of Lake Erie to characterize tissue variation and geographic trends. The locations included the Ohio Areas of Concern, i.e., the Ashtabula, Black, and Maumee Rivers; the Ottawa River near Toledo; and two reference sites. Mean total PCBs were greatest in turtles from the Ottawa River followed by the Maumee, Ashtabula, and Black Rivers. All three types of samples-fat tissue (FT), eggs, and plasma-showed the same geographic trend in PCB levels. On a wet-weight basis, mean concentrations ranged from 2,148 to 18,669 ng/g in FT, from 183 to 3,683 ng/g in eggs, and from 18 to 201 ng/g in plasma. Across all sites, total PCB concentrations between the tissues were significantly correlated (0.001 < p < 0.005; Pearson correlation coefficient (r ( P )) was between 0.720 and 0.954). Two distinctly different profiles with respect to relative congener and homologue concentrations were found among the sites. One that included four of the six sites examined was characterized by hexa-chlorobiphenyl (hexa-CB) dominance followed by hepta-CBs, with PCBs no. 138 + 163, 153 + 132 + 105, and 180 being the most abundant congeners. The second profile, specific for turtles from the Ottawa River, was different from the first in that tetra-CBs were the most abundant congeners followed by hexa-CBs. Analysis of variance (ANOVA) indicated significant intertissue differences in the PCB homologue profiles, i.e., FT had a higher percentage of hepta-, octa-, and nona-CBs compared with eggs and plasma, whereas eggs showed a higher percentage of hexa-CBs. At any listed location, FT, eggs, and plasma had the same congener profile. An intertissue distribution of lipid-normalized individual congener concentrations examined by regression analyses revealed significant egg-FT, egg-plasma, and FT-plasma relations for >40 congeners (0.001 < p < 0.05). The distribution ratios determined for these congeners from the slope of the regression lines averaged 1.235 +/- 0.279, 0.430 +/- 0.170, and 0.387 +/- 0.115, respectively. The plasma wet weight-FT lipid-normalized concentration ratios for these congeners averaged 0.012 +/- 0.006. Both egg-FT and plasma wet weight-FT lipid-normalized ratios regressed against log K(ow) showed significant decreases, with increasing log K(ow), indicating greater accumulation of highly chlorinated congeners in FT than in other compartments. The estimated 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin toxic equivalents ranged from 0.007 ng/g at reference sites to 0.060 ng/g at contaminated sites and from 0.099 to 1.992 ng/g in plasma and eggs, respectively. In both plasma and eggs, coplanar-CBs were the major contributors to total toxic equivalents (TEQs). Eggs from all contaminated sites had TEQs that exceeded the lowest observed effect level TEQs proposed for bald eagle chicks, in addition to high SigmaPCB levels at some of these sites, especially the Ottawa and Maumee River sites, indicate potentially increased risk to turtles and possibly other wildlife species inhabiting these ecosystems. Significant correlations of total PCBs and individual congeners between FT, eggs, and plasma indicate that blood sampling can provide a good nonlethal measure of PCB exposure and can be used to monitor environmental contamination.
测定了来自伊利湖俄亥俄盆地六个地点的成年鳄龟(蛇鳄龟指名亚种)三种组织中多氯联苯(PCBs)的浓度和分布特征,以表征组织差异和地理趋势。这些地点包括俄亥俄州的受关注区域,即阿什塔比拉河、布莱克河和莫米河;托莱多附近的渥太华河;以及两个参考地点。渥太华河的龟体内总多氯联苯平均含量最高, 其次是莫米河、阿什塔比拉河和布莱克河。所有三种类型的样本——脂肪组织(FT)、卵和血浆——在多氯联苯水平上呈现相同的地理趋势。以湿重计,脂肪组织中平均浓度范围为2148至18669 ng/g,卵中为183至3683 ng/g,血浆中为18至201 ng/g。在所有地点,各组织之间的总多氯联苯浓度显著相关(0.001 < p < 0.005;皮尔逊相关系数(r(P))在0.720至0.954之间)。在这些地点中发现了两种关于相对同系物和同源物浓度的明显不同的分布特征。其中一种包括六个检测地点中的四个,其特征是六氯联苯(hexa-CB)占主导地位,其次是七氯联苯,多氯联苯138 + 163、153 + 132 + 105和180是最丰富的同系物。第二种分布特征,特定于渥太华河的龟,与第一种不同,四氯联苯是最丰富的同系物,其次是六氯联苯。方差分析(ANOVA)表明多氯联苯同源物分布特征在组织间存在显著差异,即脂肪组织中七氯、八氯和九氯联苯的百分比高于卵和血浆,而卵中六氯联苯的百分比更高。在任何列出的地点,脂肪组织、卵和血浆具有相同的同系物分布特征。通过回归分析检查的脂质标准化个体同系物浓度的组织间分布显示,超过40种同系物存在显著的卵-脂肪组织、卵-血浆和脂肪组织-血浆关系(0.001 < p < 0.05)。根据回归线斜率确定的这些同系物的分布比率平均分别为1.235±0.279、0.430±0.170和0.387±0.115。这些同系物的血浆湿重-脂肪组织脂质标准化浓度比率平均为0.012±0.006。卵-脂肪组织和血浆湿重-脂肪组织脂质标准化比率与log Kow的回归均显示随着log Kow的增加而显著降低,表明高度氯化的同系物在脂肪组织中的积累比在其他区室中更多。估计的2,3,7,8-四氯二苯并对二恶英毒性当量范围从参考地点的0.007 ng/g到污染地点的0.060 ng/g,血浆和卵中的分别为0.099至1.992 ng/g。在血浆和卵中,共平面多氯联苯是总毒性当量(TEQs)的主要贡献者。所有污染地点的卵的毒性当量均超过了为白头鹰雏鸟提议的最低观察效应水平毒性当量,此外,其中一些地点,特别是渥太华河和莫米河地点的多氯联苯总含量很高,表明龟以及可能栖息在这些生态系统中的其他野生动物物种面临的风险可能增加。脂肪组织、卵和血浆之间总多氯联苯和单个同系物的显著相关性表明,血液采样可以提供一种良好的非致死性多氯联苯暴露测量方法,并可用于监测环境污染。